Cabinet shuffle math

Presented by Public Service Alliance of Canada: A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Dec 11, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO Ottawa Playbook Newsletter Header

By Mickey Djuric and Nick Taylor-Vaisey

Presented by Public Service Alliance of Canada

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Ottawa Playbook | Follow Politico Canada

Thanks for reading Ottawa Playbook. Let's get into it.

In today's edition:

→ The who, when and why of Trudeau’s next Cabinet shuffle.

→ Late night with DONALD TRUMP. 

DRIVING THE DAY


OUT WITH THE OLD — Ottawa insiders say a January Cabinet shuffle is inevitable — at the very latest.

Let’s start with the math:

Two ministers — ANITA ANAND and GINETTE PETITPAS TAYLOR — are each carrying multiple portfolios following the exit of former Transport Minister PABLO RODRIGUEZ and Employment Minister RANDY BOISSONNAULT.

Four more ministers — MARIE-CLAUDE BIBEAU, CARLA QUALTROUGH, FILOMENA TASSI and DAN VANDAL — have announced they don’t plan to run in the next election.

— Step right up: In light of that, some MPs around town are reminding anyone who’ll listen of their unwavering loyalty to Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU — even through the attempted caucus revolt this fall.

— High stakes: This is probably Trudeau’s final major Cabinet shuffle — and the last chance for backbenchers to make the cut.

— Don’t get too excited: A shuffle is unlikely to change the Liberals’ political fortunes. Remember in 2023 when the PMO attempted to shake things up? Liberals still remain a distant second to the Conservatives, national opinion polls show.

At this point it might feel like the government is handing out Cabinet spots to MPs who have yet to sit at the big table.

“This may be like the World Cup circa 2014, where Germany just destroyed Brazil and everybody got a chance to score a goal. You get a goal, you get a goal, you get a goal,” said SHACHI KURL, president of Angus Reid Institute.

“It’s that last opportunity to elevate a few backbenchers who haven’t had the chance to sit in Cabinet and really want that. But what’s the upside or benefit for the government at this stage?”

 

A message from Public Service Alliance of Canada:

Tell the Liberals to keep their hands off workers’ pensions. Learn more.

 


CALENDAR WATCH — The timing of annual winter Cabinet retreats and occasional January shuffles have dotted the monthly calendar since Trudeau took office.

They’ve happened to varying degrees in the Trudeau years. Remember when JODY WILSON-RAYBOULD was moved from justice to veterans affairs? That was Jan. 14, 2019. FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE took over his current portfolio on Jan. 12, 2021.

→ Annual routines: Shuffles ordinarily drop in the second week of the month. Trudeau has never hosted a Cabinet retreat or shuffled his front bench earlier than Jan. 8 — and no later than Jan. 26.

He rarely schedules retreats or shuffles over January weekends.

→ No-go zones: If the Liberals hope the musical chairs own a news cycle, they'll avoid Jan. 20, when Trump’s inauguration will preoccupy just about everybody.

Statistics Canada drops inflation data Jan. 21, and TIFF MACKLEM is due for an interest rate announcement on Jan. 29.

— What's left: Jan. 9-10, Jan. 13-17 and Jan. 22-24 — if, that is, the Prime Minister's Office doesn't buck any of its annual routines.

→ Don't forget Davos: The World Economic Forum meets Jan. 20-24 in the Swiss resort town known to attract, say, Finance Minister CHRYSTIA FREELAND.

— Challenges ahead: “You need a Cabinet that is able to deal with our largest trading partner and you have to have a Cabinet that is putting forward the best case for re-election,” said GREG MACEACHERN, principal and founder of KAN Strategies.

A January refresh would give ministers a couple weeks with their files before Parliament returns, and before Trump gets back to the White House.

“You’re also not facing political media coverage driven by question period — or as JOHN TURNER calls it, bullshit theatre,” said MacEachern.

STUART BARNABLE, vice president at Hill+Knowlton Strategies, says the government is facing its hardest shuffle since 2015.

Trudeau will face an election at some point in 2025. In the meantime, his Cabinet will deal with constant rhetoric from Trump and the threat of tariffs, Barnable said. Not to mention unhappy caucus members, who could become even unhappier if they’re passed by for Cabinet.

“Both externally and now internally, the Trudeau government has a lot to face and the front benches are going to be the front line in those battles, be it internally or external,” Barnable said.

CABINET WATCH — The PM likes to have gender parity in his Cabinet while keeping it regionally balanced. Among the names floating around regionally:

B.C.: There’s speculation TALEEB NOORMOHAMED could replace Qualtrough.

Alberta: There are just two Liberal MPs in a province that often accuses Ottawa of ignoring its interests. Boissonnault was recently sacked from Cabinet. And GEORGE CHAHAL was among the lawmakers to sign a statement calling on the PM to resign.

So … who knows?

Manitoba: TERRY DUGUID or BEN CARR could replace Vandal.

Ontario: CHARLES SOUSA, former Ontario finance minister, or RYAN TURNBULL, another parl sec to the finance minister, have been named as replacements for Tassi.

Quebec: ANNA GAINEY, former Liberal Party president and a close friend of the PM’s, or RACHEL BENDAYAN, parliamentary secretary to the finance minister, could take the place of Bibeau.

Indigenous representation: Vandal is the only Indigenous member of Cabinet. His exit could place Nova Scotia MP JAIME BATTISTE — parliamentary secretary to the Crown-Indigenous relations minister — in the running. Another option is for Vandal to stay in Cabinet, though that would go against the Liberals’ usual practice of replacing members who are not seeking reelection.

THE TOP CHALLENGE — Those who spoke to Playbook agree: A shuffle is not likely to sway public opinion. That’s because the Cabinet has a PM problem.

“The most important thing in terms of the political fate of the government will be how Canadians feel about the PM and about the government as a whole,” said ALEX COHEN, former director of communications to several Liberal ministers. “In that regard, it’s a little more limited what a shuffle could do.”

 

Billions in spending. Critical foreign aid. Immigration reform. The final weeks of 2024 could bring major policy changes. Inside Congress provides daily insights into how Congressional leaders are navigating these high-stakes issues. Subscribe today.

 
 
Where the leaders are


— Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will attend caucus and host a virtual meeting with provincial and territorial premiers. The Star sets up that confab.

— DPM CHRYSTIA FREELAND will attend caucus and join the first ministers’ meeting.

— Conservative Leader PIERRE POILIEVRE will attend his caucus meeting.

— Bloc Québécois Leader YVES-FRANÇOIS BLANCHET has not released his itinerary.

— NDP Leader JAGMEET SINGH will attend his caucus meeting and speak to the media before QP.

— Green Party Leader ELIZABETH MAY will meet with Canadians for Tax Fairness and gather with her party caucus. Later in the day, she’ll attend QP and ask a Q.

DULY NOTED


9:45 a.m. A majority of economists polled by Reuters expect Bank of Canada Governor TIFF MACKLEM to cut interest rates by a half percentage point this morning.

6 p.m. Foreign Minister MÉLANIE JOLY headlines a "fundraising cocktail" at Montreal's Centre PHI.

TRUMPQUAKE

Then-Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump smiles at an election night watch party.

Donald Trump lobbed some late-night digs at Justin Trudeau this week. | Evan Vucci/AP

When DONALD TRUMP mentions Canada, we take note. We see you, anxious politicians, staffers, lobbyists, public servants, diplomats, activists, academics — and, well, everybody else who is reading this. Yes, this will be the next four years.

Don’t hate the player, hate the game.

TALKING POINTS — The president-elect threw a late-night dig at Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU on Truth Social on Tuesday, calling him the “governor” of the “the Great State of Canada.”

— Vibe shift: When Trump was trolling Canada last week, Public Safety Minister DOMINIC LEBLANC brushed it off as a joke.

— Tired joke: This week, Cabinet is no longer chalking it up as funny. Instead, many ministers are doing their very best not to engage.

The Prime Minister’s Office, the U.S. embassy in Canada, and the Canadian embassy in the U.S. all declined to comment.

Here’s who couldn’t resist:

— Deputy Prime Minister CHRYSTIA FREELAND: “I truly am going to urge everyone who has questions to the president-elect to pose those to him. I am so proud of our country, so proud of the true north, strong and free, and I also want to say to Canadians that our government is absolutely determined to defend the national interest. We will do so.”

— Health Minister MARK HOLLAND: “Jokes are made, and you try to have levity, and I’m sure that that’s the context in which this has happened.”

— Veterans Affairs Minister GINETTE PETITPAS TAYLOR: “We’re going to focus on Canadians and making sure we work collaboratively with the president of the United States.”

— Immigration Minister MARC MILLER: “Sounds like we’re living in an episode of ‘South Park.’”

— Last word to Defense Minister BILL BLAIR: “I don’t take offense at jokes.”

More reading: CP’s KYLE DUGGAN and JORDAN OMSTEAD report on a new poll that suggests 13 percent of Canadians think Canada should become the 51st American state

 

A message from Public Service Alliance of Canada:

Advertisement Image

 
MEDIA ROOM


— From NICK MURRAY of CP: MPs approve $21.6-billion in supplementary spending;(Conservatives voted against.)

— The Star's RYAN TUMILTY shares news of a privy council memo to the PM that warns that America’s massive debt and deficit could cause problems in Canada.

MARIE WOOLF and DAVE CHAN report from "the slash" along the Quebec-New York State border.

SUSHANT SINGH writes in The Walrus on the killing of a Canadian Sikh that has been linked to the highest levels of India’s government.

— From OLIVIA STEFANOVICH of CBC News: Poilievre's 'Santa Claus' quip trivialized Inuit presence in Arctic, says national Inuit leader.

RAYMOND ZHONG of The New York Times reports that wildfires and thawing permafrost are causing the Arctic to release more carbon dioxide than its plants remove, probably for the first time in thousands of years.

JORGE ANTUNES of Nunatsiaq News reports that Pond Inlet’s hamlet council has voted not to host cruise ship visits next year since Parks Canada took over the community hub where local artisans and staff served tourists.

 

Write your own chapter in the new Washington. From the Lame Duck Congress Series to New Administration insights, POLITICO Pro delivers intelligence across 22+ policy areas to help you anticipate and navigate change. Discover how a Pro subscription empowers you. Learn more today.

 
 
PROZONE


For POLITICO subscribers, our latest policy newsletter by MIKE BLANCHFIELD: Governor Trudeau, I presume.

And the latest headlines:

Warming Arctic has shifted to become a driver of climate change, federal scientists say.

EU’s climate chief warns of “geopolitical winter.”

In a shift, Biden to bar most fossil fuel financing overseas.

Europe urges global treaty on limiting sunlight. Trump could block it.

Rapidly warming Arctic has entered a “new regime.”

PLAYBOOKERS

Birthdays: HBD to Independent MP ALAIN RAYES. HBD + 1 to MARK RAMZY.

Got a document to share? A birthday coming up? Send it our way.

Spotted: Former B.C. Premier CHRISTY CLARK, and federal Liberal leader hopeful, door knocking in Surrey for the upcoming federal byelection in Cloverdale—Langley City.

Federation of Canadian Municipalities CEO CAROLE SAAB, chatting with Conservative MP and housing critic SCOTT AITCHISON.

Noted: Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will headline a Liberal fundraiser tomorrow evening at the Sheraton Vancouver Airport Hotel in Richmond, British Columbia. Also on the bill: Emergency Preparedness Minister HARJIT SAJJAN.

— QP scenes: Finance Minister CHRYSTIA FREELAND, lugging a characteristically bulky binder into the House … Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU, late to a standing ovation for Freeland — tardiness noted by jeering Tories across the way … Trudeau, receiving applause mostly from MPs in the camera shot as off-camera colleagues scrolled and typed … Conservative MP LIANNE ROOD, applying eye drops before asking a question directly into the camera across the aisle (to the enjoyment of nearby Liberals GEORGE CHAHAL and KODY BLOIS) ...

… An anti-homelessness activist, hollering from the public gallery before being escorted out … NDP MP BONITA ZARRILLO, referring to the presence of the protester three times before Speaker GREG FERGUS ordered her to rephrase her question … Former Alberta Premier JASON KENNEY, seated in the front row of the public gallery.

— At the Equal Voice gala: Women from every major party caucus alongside past and future candidates … TikTok, sponsoring the event on the same day as its lawyers filed a legal challenge of Ottawa's decision to shut down the company's Canadian operations.

PM Trudeau, firing off a partisan speech about women in politics that pooh-poohed STEPHEN HARPER's record in office, shouted out his governing greatest hits and reminded the room that the U.S. recently "chose not to elect its first woman as president" for the second time in a decade. Trudeau was met with steady applause.

Conservative Deputy Leader MELISSA LANTSMAN, replying with a fiery speech that insisted the success of women in politics "can't be about gender-balanced Cabinet or a humankind dictionary." Lantsman argued against "a lot of pretty words" and for "real results for real people." Lantsman was met with increasing applause.

NDP Leader JAGMEET SINGH, lamenting "older white men" who "fail upwards" and celebrating a future in which his two daughters can thrive.

Green Leader ELIZABETH MAY, imploring politicians: "Don't tear each other down." May closed on a call to the gala-goers in the room: "We are not freeloaders. We donate!"

Media mentions: Submissions are open for the Canadian Journalism Foundation's 2025 awards and fellowships. … Nominations for the 2025 Press Freedom Awards are open … National Newspaper Awards are taking entries … The National Media Awards Foundation is accepting submissions for the 2025 Digital Publishing Awards

 

A message from Public Service Alliance of Canada:

The Liberal government must back down and reverse this unfair attack against pensions. Learn more.

 
ON THE HILL


Find the latest House meetings here. The Senate schedule is here.

12 p.m. The Senate subcommittee on veterans affairs meets to discuss veterans’ homelessness.

4:15 p.m. The Senate foreign affairs committee will hear from the senior envoys of South Africa, Rwanda, Cameroon and Morocco about Canada’s interests in Africa.

4:15 p.m. The Senate legal affairs committee meets to consider the Corrections and Conditional Release Act.

4:30 p.m. The House fisheries committee will study the Fisheries Act.

4:30 p.m. The House status of women committee hears evidence on hate-motivated violence.

4:30 p.m. The House environment committee studies the Convention on Biological Diversity.

4:30 p.m. The House international trade committee will consider the trade impacts of Canada’s leadership in reducing emissions. On the meeting roster: Aluminium Association of Canada, the Canadian Climate Institute, Canadian Union of Public Employees and the United Steelworkers.

6:45 p.m. The Senate finance committee meets to consider supplementary estimates.

6:45 p.m. The Senate transport committee hears evidence on copper wire theft.

Behind closed doors: The House budget subcommittee on committee budgets meets. The House public accounts committee will consider recommendations by the auditor general. The House natural resources committee meets to consider a draft report on Canada’s electricity grid. The Senate social affairs committee meets to consider a draft report on the Citizenship Act.

Talk of the town


ATTENTION TRIVIA NERDS — We’re hosting Playbook Trivia in Washington on Monday, Dec. 16 at Astro Beer Hall, a couple of blocks from the White House. Doors open at 7 p.m. First question at 7:30. Registration is open. Tables are filling up. Space is limited. RSVP via this Google Form

TRIVIA


Tuesday’s answer: JOHN PETERS HUMPHREY played a major role in the draft of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

Props to GEOFFREY CHAMBERS, ORI EPSTEIN,  NANCI WAUGH, CHIP SMITH, KAY STANLEY, JOHN MERRIMAN, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, STEPHEN HAAS, RALPH LEVENSTEIN, LAURA JARVIS, TRACY SALMON, ​​SHAUGHN MCARTHUR, MARC SHAW, RAY DEL BIANCO, MICHAEL WERNICK, STACEY NORONHA and MARCEL MARCOTTE.

Wednesday’s question: In honor of Trump’s latest quip about Canada becoming a 51st state, we look back at a former territorial dispute. Canada and the United States had a longstanding Alaska boundary dispute over a contested area that is now known as what?

Answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Writing tomorrow's Playbook: NICK TAYLOR-VAISEY.

Playbook wouldn’t happen without: POLITICO Canada editor Sue Allan, editor Willa Plank and Luiza Ch. Savage.

Want to advertise in Ottawa Playbook? Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: jshapiro@politico.com.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Mike Blanchfield @ @mblanchfield

Mickey Djuric @MickeyDjuric

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post