Canada has a growing populism problem. Even Prime Minister Justin Trudeau thinks so.
Like many other countries — including the United States — Canadians have spent the last several years dealing with pandemic restrictions, a rise in immigration, and a housing affordability crisis (among much, much else). And like many other countries, that's showing up in a host of ways: Trust in institutions like the government and media is down. Sentiment on immigration is becoming more negative.
"Well, first of all, it's a global trend," Trudeau told Sean Rameswaram in an exclusive interview on Today, Explained. "In every democracy, we're seeing a rise of populists with easy answers that don't necessarily hold up to any expert scrutiny. But a big part of populism is condemning and ignoring experts and expertise. So it sort of feeds on itself."
As Trudeau points out, Canada is not alone. But our northern neighbor's struggle is notable because the country has long been seen as resistant to the kind of anti-immigrant, anti-establishment rhetoric sweeping the globe in recent years — in part because multiculturalism is enshrined in federal law.
It goes back to the 1960s, when French Canadian nationalist groups started to gain power in Quebec. They called for the province's independence from Canada proper.
The federal government, led then by nepo daddy Pierre Trudeau, stepped in. Rather than validating one cultural identity over the other, the elder Trudeau's government established a national policy of bilingualism, requiring all federal institutions to provide services in both English and French. (This is why — if you ever watch Canadian parliamentary proceedings, as I did for this story — politicians are constantly flipping back and forth between the two languages.)
Canada also adopted a formal multiculturalism policy in 1971, affirming Canadians' multicultural heritage.
The multiculturalism policy has undergone both challenge and expansion in the half-century since its introduction. But Pierre Trudeau's decision to root Canadian identity in diversity has had lasting impacts: Canadians have historically been much more open to immigration — despite having a greater proportion of immigrants in their population — than their other Western counterparts.
But in more recent years, that's begun to change rapidly as large numbers of immigrants have entered the country amid a housing affordability crisis. An Environics Institute survey showed that in 2023, 44 percent of Canadians felt there was too much immigration — an increase from 27 percent the year before.
That's where Conservative opposition leader Pierre Poilievre comes in. Known as a "soft" populist, he's started calling on Canada to cut immigration levels (so far, without demonizing immigrants, as we've seen from his populist counterparts elsewhere in the West).
That said, he looks like a traditional populist in a lot of other ways: Poilievre embraced Canada's 2022 Freedom Convoy protests, opposed vaccine and mask requirements, voted against marriage equality, has proposed defunding the Canadian Broadcasting Service, wants schools to leave LGBTQ issues to parents, and has talked about repealing a litany of government regulations — from the country's carbon tax to internet regulations. Basically, he's against any "gatekeepers" to Canadians' "freedom."
And that message? It seems to be resonating with voters, including young ones.
