It’s 2008 all over again

Presented by L'Oréal: Inside the Golden State political arena
Oct 18, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO California Playbook Newsletter Header

By Dustin Gardiner and Lara Korte

Presented by 

L'Oréal

Joni Boettcher (left) kisses Tika Shenghur during a protest march.

Supporters of ballot measure to enshrine same-sex marriage rights in California say it's a chance to put forward a more inclusive image of the LGBTQ community. | Kevork Djansezian/AP

THE BUZZ: 2ND TIME DOWN THE AISLE — Supporters of same-sex marriage are trying to pull off a redo of 2008 — in more ways than one.

First, they want voters to approve Proposition 3, a ballot measure that would enshrine marriage rights in the California Constitution by repealing a ban on same-sex unions that voters narrowly approved that year.

But they also want to heal wounds left by the prior marriage equality campaign itself, which faced criticism for largely focusing on white, cisgender gay and lesbian couples, thereby dividing the community.

From the faces used in campaign ads to the political groups at the helm, the unsuccessful effort to defeat the Proposition 8 ban often excluded people of color and the transgender community.

The group behind this November’s effort say the campaign is a chance for a do-over, soothing the rifts left in the wake of Prop 8 and depicting the kaleidoscope of diversity among LGBTQ people.

The new TV and print ads reflect that shift in strategy, featuring more Latino, Asian, Native American and Black people, as well as couples that include trans and gender non-conforming spouses.

The new strategy shows how the push for same-sex marriage has evolved over the past 16 years, in particular the messaging toward communities of color, which were previously targeted heavily by the Prop 8 campaign advocating the ban. It also shows the confidence campaigners now have in passing their measure as many conservatives have accepted defeat on marriage equality.

“In the past, it was mainly driven by white people,” said Bamby Salcedo , president of the Trans Latina Coalition, a Los-Angeles based group that is part of the campaign’s executive committee. “This time around, we believe it’s an inclusive campaign. We have a seat at the table.”

While same-sex marriage is now legal nationwide due to the Supreme Court, proponents fear that could change if the high court veers more conservative, especially after overturning Roe v. Wade.

They also hope a more inclusive image of the LGBTQ community will help unite the community in the face of Republican lawmakers and school boards across the country pushing policies to limit the rights of trans people and others.

The Yes on Prop 3 campaign debuted its first TV ad this month, part of a roughly $3 million statewide advertising effort during the final weeks of the election. Organizers say the spot reflects the campaign’s aspiration to heal past wounds.

“Everyone, every race and gender, should have the freedom to marry who they love,” the ad states as images of Pride parades and dozens of smiling couples play on the screen.

Rick Chavez Zbur , a Democratic state Assemblymember and the former director of Equality California, said campaigns around same-sex marriage in past decades were often driven by the political reality of the time: That organizers had a limited window to try to block marriage bans by appealing to conservative-leaning voters with arguments about protecting individual rights.

But Chavez Zbur said leaders of the LGBTQ movement have made an intentional effort over the last 15+ years to include more diversity within their ranks to prevent mistakes of the past. He’s launched his own ad in support of Prop 3 that also reflects the effort to include more people of color and a wider spectrum of genders.

“Today, we are in a position of not having to change hearts and minds so much,” Chavez Zbur said. “Now, the main goal of the campaign is getting our voters to the polls.”

The ads target voters in five different languages, including English, Spanish, Korean, simplified Chinese and Tagalog. In addition, the campaign has partnered with local groups around the state to create digital and newspaper ads tailored to reach voters of color and ethnic media audiences.

Courtni Pugh , campaign manager for Yes on Prop 3, said while polling suggests the measure will easily pass in deep-blue California — it’s hardly faced any organized opposition — the group also wants to run a campaign that sends a loud signal of support to other states grappling with tougher debates over LGBTQ rights.

“It is sometimes how you win,” she said.

GOOD MORNING. Happy Friday. Thanks for waking up with Playbook.

You can text us at ‪916-562-0685‬‪ — save it as “CA Playbook” in your contacts. Or drop us a line at lkorte@politico.com and dgardiner@politico.com, or on X — @DustinGardiner and @Lara_Korte.

WHERE’S GAVIN? Campaigning for Democratic nominee Kamala Harris in Michigan.

 

A message from L'Oréal:

Approximately 65% of Americans have textured hair – coiled, curly, or wavy. California’s new law, Textured Hair Education Bill (AB 2166), addresses the unique needs of these hair types by providing education for beauty professionals. Thanks to Gov. Gavin Newsom & Dr. Akilah Weber, this ensures all Californians are seen and celebrated in the salon chair.

 
CAMPAIGN YEAR

California Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas speaks on stage at the Los Angeles Equality Awards.

Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas. | Rich Polk/Getty Images for Equality California

FIRST IN PLAYBOOK: NO LOVE FOR LOW — Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas is snubbing a member of his Democratic caucus and endorsing Sam Liccardo in the bitter Dem-on-Dem race for an open Silicon Valley House seat. The speaker endorsed Liccardo, the former mayor of San Jose, over longtime Assembly colleague Evan Low, the campaign exclusively told Playbook.

It’s unusual for a sitting speaker to pass over one of their own, but not entirely unexpected in this case. Rivas and Low have a history of bad blood: Low briefly made his own play for speaker in 2022, as Rivas ultimately ousted Anthony Rendon to take control of the chamber.

In a statement, Rivas said Liccardo has shown he “can work across the aisle” to get things done and he lauded the former mayor for “taking on big oil” a potential nod to environmental groups that have criticized Low for taking oil industry money.

Mug shots of George Whitesides (left) and Mike Garcia for California house races

AD TRACKER — Two Republican PACs are using George Whitesides’ support for the state’s largest LGBTQ group to argue that the Democratic candidate supports lowering penalties for pedophiles — a misleading claim that critics say echoes a common dog whistle for conservative conspiracy theorists.

Whitesides is running in a tight race against incumbent Republican Rep. Mike Garcia in CA-27, north of Los Angeles. Two ads launched this week from the NRCC and Congressional Leadership Fund highlight Whitesides’ record of donating to Equality California and insinuating the group protects pedophiles from criminal punishments.

Four years ago, Equality California sponsored legislation that changed state law to treat oral and anal sex acts between a young adult and minor the same as vaginal sexual intercourse. Prior to the bill, SB 145, young adults convicted of oral or anal sex with a minor were automatically added to the state’s sex offender registry — a policy that some viewed as a prejudicial relic of the state’s old anti-sodomy laws that were aimed at criminalizing sex between men.

Now, judges have a choice in cases of oral or anal sex with a minor as to whether to add the young adult to the sex offender list — the same way they have discretion in cases involving vaginal sexual intercourse between a minor girl and a young adult man.

The bill faced fierce opposition from Republicans in the Legislature when it was introduced in 2020, with some conservative opponents using it as a rallying cry and spreading false claims that California was legalizing pedophilia.

Similar themes have appeared in this year’s campaign ads. The NRCC spot depicts dark scenes of child abduction: playground swings left empty, bikes abandoned on the street, and a computer open to an online chatroom, surrounded by pictures of supposed child victims.

"George Whitesides funded a group opposing pedophiles registering as sex offenders," the ad says in closing. "Don't allow George Whitesides into Congress."

NRCC spokesperson Ben Petersen, in a statement, said: “Our ad is factually accurate and a public service announcement voters cannot trust George Whitesides. Whitesides bankrolled soft-on-crime activist groups behind extreme policies like this one.”

The CLF ad similarly highlights Whitesides’ connections to Equality California and its support for the 2020 bill, saying “some adults could have sex with teens as young as 15 without having to register as a sex offender.” Given that judges had previously had discretion over that decision in cases of vaginal sexual intercourse, that fact would have been true even before the legislation in question.

“George Whitesides might not like that he got caught funding all sorts of extreme politicians and groups, but the simple fact is these policies weakened penalties for sex offenders and jeopardized the safety of minors," said CLF spokesperson Courtney Parella.

Tom Temprano, Equality California’s managing director of external affairs, said the bill did not stop anyone from being added to the sex offender registry list.

“These ads are designed to tear us apart, and are filled with the same old anti-LGBTQ+ lies that far-right politicians have been using to try and divide us for decades,” he said in a statement.

Emma Harris , a spokesperson for the Whitesides campaign, said in a statement: “As the father of two kids, 12 and 14, George puts the safety of his family before all else. Unfortunately for the GOP, these baseless attacks on Democrats up and down the state won't work, and voters will see right through these lies.”

 

A message from L'Oréal:

Advertisement Image

 
CLIMATE AND ENERGY

SHARE THE WEALTH — San Francisco transit advocates are campaigning for a tax on Uber and Lyft to fund the city’s struggling transit system. Voters' answer in November could have ripple effects across a state where public transportation is on the precipice of a fiscal cliff. Read more in last night’s California Climate.

TOP TALKERS

San Francisco Mayor London Breed gestures during an election night party.

San Francisco Mayor London Breed. | Godofredo A. Vásquez/AP Photo

ENDORSEMENT DYNAMICS — London Breed sent an email to supporters Wednesday celebrating the San Francisco Chronicle for endorsing her as “the safe choice for mayor.” Except that’s not how the Chronicle editorial board actually saw it, the paper’s news team reports.

Indeed, the quote snipped for the incumbent mayor’s fundraising email was part of the Chronicle’s endorsement headline. But the latter half went on to label nonprofit founder and Levi Strauss heir Daniel Lurie as the only candidate that fits “if you think SF needs change.” The key phrase describing Lurie as their pick came in the last sentence of the Chron’s more than 1,500-word endorsement: “If you genuinely think San Francisco would benefit from a change, as we do, then Lurie is a risk worth taking.”

Breed’s camp is still sticking by the email. “Our campaign email used the Chronicle’s own words, directly from the endorsement, to highlight the shared concerns we have about Daniel Lurie’s inexperience,” said Breed campaign spokesperson Joe Arellano. “This is much ado about nothing.”

‘YOU JUST BAN IT’ — A transgender San Jose State University student playing on the women’s volleyball team has generated debate within West Coast collegiate sports and has now caught the attention of Donald Trump. The former president during a Fox News town hall that aired Wednesday cited the player as an example when he promised to issue an executive order outlawing transgender competitors at all levels.

“You just ban it,” Trump said. “The president bans it. You just don’t let it happen.”

BUSINESS BUDDIES — Elon Musk has forged a relationship with a Republican figure who could open up a geyser of federal cash for his Starlink satellite internet business — and it’s not the person running for president. It’s Brendan Carr, the senior Republican on the Federal Communications Commission. And should Trump win in November, the unusual link between a regulator and his potential beneficiary could mean a payday is coming for the world’s richest man, POLITICO’s John Hendel reports this morning.

 

A message from L'Oréal:

Approximately 65% of Americans have textured hair – coiled, curly, or wavy. Yet, for far too long, cosmetology training has overlooked the unique needs of these hair types. California’s new law, Textured Hair Education Bill (AB 2166), addresses this by providing education for beauty professionals. Thanks to Gov. Gavin Newsom and Dr. Akilah Weber, this ensures that all Californians are seen and celebrated in the salon chair. The Professional Products Division of L'Oréal is a proud founding member of the Texture Education Collective (TEC), an alliance of professional hair industry leaders working together to influence cosmetology state board licensing requirements and curriculums to be inclusive of all hair textures and all hair types.

 
AROUND THE STATE

— Report claims the former chief of San Francisco’s “Dream Keeper” social equity program used her city position to boost her personal brand. (San Francisco Chronicle)

— A former Canadian Olympic snowboarder stands accused of running a drug trafficking organization that moved cocaine from Colombia to Canada via Southern California. (Los Angeles Times)

— Condé Nast readers voted a California town the No. 1 “food city” in the U.S., and it wasn’t San Francisco or Los Angeles. (Condé Nast)

— How Kamala Harris changed these six Californians’ lives. (Los Angeles Times)

PLAYBOOKERS

PEOPLE MOVES — Jeff Marschner of Stanford University’s Hoover Institution was recently promoted to assistant director for media and government relations and D.C. operations at the Washington office. Lauren Wright, who previously worked in the late Sen. John McCain’s office and at the Aspen Institute, was named senior manager of government relations focusing on Capitol Hill and executive branch engagement.

Justin Angel Knighten , associate administrator of the Office of External Affairs at FEMA and a Sacramento native, was recently honored as PR Professional of the Year at the PRSA ICON 2024 conference.

BIRTHDAYS — FOX LA anchor Elex Michaelson Rep. Young Kim (R-Calif.) … Walt Disney Co.’s Caitlin Conant

WANT A SHOUT-OUT FEATURED? — Send us a birthday, career move or another special occasion to include in POLITICO’s California Playbook. You can now submit a shout-out using this Google form.

CALIFORNIA POLICY IS ALWAYS CHANGING: Know your next move. From Sacramento to Silicon Valley, POLITICO California Pro provides policy professionals with the in-depth reporting and tools they need to get ahead of policy trends and political developments shaping the Golden State. To learn more about the exclusive insight and analysis this subscriber-only service offers, click here.

Want to make an impact? POLITICO California has a variety of solutions available for partners looking to reach and activate the most influential people in the Golden State. Have a petition you want signed? A cause you’re promoting? Seeking to increase brand awareness amongst this key audience? Share your message with our influential readers to foster engagement and drive action. Contact Rebecca Haase to find out how: rhaase@politico.com.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Dustin Gardiner @dustingardiner

Lara Korte @lara_korte

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post