GROWING PAINS — Donald Trump has supercharged the international right, serving as an inspiration to right-leaning populist movements across the globe. Yet Trump’s embrace of Russian President Vladimir Putin, his rough treatment of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and his suspension of aid to the embattled nation fighting off a Russian invasion is revealing the seams in the burgeoning global alliance. Among Trump’s European fellow travelers, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has long been a staunch supporter of Ukraine aid and Marine LePen, the leader of the National Rally in France, strongly condemned Trump’s decision to cut off support to Ukraine calling it “reprehensible and cruel” in a newspaper interview on Tuesday. Dutch far-right leader Geert Wilders, after initially responding cautiously, declared: "Of course, the PVV supports Ukraine and with conviction," he said, referring to his Party for Freedom. Even Nigel Farage, the leader of the Reform Party in the United Kingdom who has long been one of Trump’s staunchest allies on either side of the Atlantic Ocean, couldn’t bring himself to support the American president. Farage said of Trump and Vice President J.D. Vance’s behavior in Friday’s Oval Office summit with Zelensky, “I’m not defending what they did.” The British MP faced a chorus of criticism domestically, however, for suggesting that the Ukrainian president should have worn a suit to the White House. This shouldn’t quite be read as a splintering of the international right wing populist movement, says Steve Bannon, the Trump ally who is one of its most prominent figures. For Bannon, who views Zelensky as “a punk” and “a crook,” it’s simply an extension of former U.S. House Speaker Tip O’Neill’s maxim that “all politics is local.” He was willing to accept the reasons for Farage and LePen to strike more pro-Ukrainian notes —- as Bannon argued, there's a different dynamic in France and the United Kingdom than there is in the U.S. He said that Farage and LePen “are playing it smartly . . because they can't totally reject the situation in Ukraine, as we have kind of the luxury here in the United States to do. So I think they're playing smart.” Bannon added, “That's the reason we're nationalists, because the politics are different in each country and we appreciate that.” However, he wasn’t so forgiving of Meloni for her support of Ukraine, saying she’s “up to her neck in this thing.” In a measure of Trump’s hold on the imagination of the international right, a number of leaders of the populist right across Europe have echoed the president’s skepticism for increased support for Zelensky and his government’s ongoing fight against the Russian invasion. Among the right wing leaders who flock to international MAGA conventions like the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in the United States, many have stood with Trump. Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban has long been a Trump ally and been supportive of his dovishness towards Putin, as have other figures on the European far right including Santiago Abascal, the leader of the Vox Party in Spain. Some have even gone further in their allegiance to Trump: Maxime Bernier, the leader of the far right People’s Party in Canada, has defended Trump’s tariffs against his own country. However, his party has no seats in Ottawa. Still, the fractures signify the inevitable tensions as right wing nationalists from across the world attempt to form a more cohesive movement. (CPAC featured both Romanian and Hungarian nationalists who have competing claims to Transylvania, which is part of Romania but still is subject to irredentist claims from Hungary.) It’s a reminder of how much, despite their differences, the international far right is unlike the far left in the 1930s, which unflaggingly followed the line of Moscow. For all the commonalities — like opposition to immigration and transgender rights — there are always international differences. After all, LePen voted to enshrine abortion rights in the French Constitution, whereas Trump has long taken credit for overturning Roe v Wade in the United States. No one would ever accuse LePen and Trump of being diametrically opposed political figures because of their differences on abortion. Instead, it’s simply that France and the United States are different countries. And, while the right wing movements share the same goal of making their respective countries “great again,” the broader international populist right is not yet dogmatic enough to require everyone taking the same path together. Welcome to POLITICO Nightly. Reach out with news, tips and ideas at nightly@politico.com. Or contact tonight’s author at bjacobs@politico.com or on X (formerly known as Twitter) at @Bencjacobs.
|