Looking for a Cabinet refresh

A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Jan 22, 2024 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Kyle Duggan and Zi-Ann Lum

Welcome to Ottawa Playbook. Let's get into it.

In today’s edition: 

→ Cabinet meets behind closed doors in Montreal for a back-to-basics refresh session and an expected string of announceables.

→ As DONALD TRUMP rockets ahead in the polling for the first primary this week, Playbook reached out to former ambassador BRUCE HEYMAN for his thoughts on what another Trump White House could mean for Canada.

TIFF MACKLEM will set the tone on rates this week at Wednesday’s scheduled policy update.

THREE THINGS WE'RE WATCHING

CAB CONFAB — Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU and his Cabinet are huddling in Montreal, angling to look refreshed ahead of Parliament’s return next week.

The Jan. 21-23 retreat is mostly focused on domestic affairs and the free-Bingo-square topic of affordability, but this one also folds in a session on the coming U.S. election — and therefore the prospect that Canada could once again face down an unpredictable DONALD TRUMP White House.

— Tackling auto theft: Public Safety Minister DOMINIC LEBLANC kicked off the announceables Sunday evening, flanked by fellow cabmins PABLO RODRIGUEZ, ANITA ANAND, FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE and ARIF VIRANI.

He said Ottawa will host a national summit on Feb. 8 on combating auto theft, an issue LeBlanc said “our caucus colleagues have raised with all of us” and that he spoke to Ontario Premier DOUG FORD about over the weekend.

“One of the things that concerns all of us is it's increasingly becoming a violent crime where people are assaulted in the process of stealing vehicles,” LeBlanc said.

The closed-door Cabinet meet comes ahead of the Liberal caucus retreat later on this week.

— Recall: Last year, the Liberals took flak for their Cabinet retreat that ended announcementless. This week, announceables on affordability and auto theft will be front-and-center.

Today, Immigration Minister MARC MILLER is expected to announce a government plan to reduce the number of international students issued permits to study in Canada.

— Golden tickets: A senior government official tells Playbook nine guest speakers will put Cabinet ministers through policy and political bootcamps on housing, the middle class and Canada-U.S. relations.

— Who’s joining the lunch line: Housing experts TIM RICHTER and MIKE MOFFATT. They’re veterans now after joining August’s Cabinet retreat.

— Money matters: Panels on issues facing Canada’s middle class will be led by UBC economics professor KEVIN MILLIGAN (who told Playbook he couldn’t talk about what he intends to tell Cabinet), Manulife chief economist FRANCES DONALD and economist ARMINE YALNIZYAN.

— 2024 watch: Cabmins will get fresh intel from Canada’s envoy in Washington, KIRSTEN HILLMAN, mined from her recent travels to Arizona and California — strategic whistle stops guided by “spreadsheets and databases” to ready Canada for America’s next president.

— Going big on manufacturing, border and trade: On Tuesday, Automotive Parts Manufacturers' Association President FLAVIO VOLPE (who recently hung out with MARCO MENDICINO and FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE in Toronto) will join Cabmins, as well as Future Borders Coalition Executive Director LAURA DAWSON and former diplomat-turned-Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec executive MARC-ANDRÉ BLANCHARD.

— Sense of urgency: Dawson tells Playbook it’s “very encouraging” that the Trudeau government seems to be “taking seriously the possibility of a second Trump presidency and what that could mean for not just Canada, but for really the international order.”

But a “Trump 2.0 will be Trump 1 on steroids,” with “no rules regarding diplomacy or treaty arrangements for institutions.”

“Some of the guardrails that we had, and some of the pro-Canadian elements that were in and around the Trump government — I don't think we can be sure of those at all,” she said.

— Time to double down on diplomacy: She said she’ll tell Cabinet, and pretty much anyone who is willing to listen, Canada needs to mobilize its allies and friends and sources of support throughout the United States, in the regions and states and cities, bringing elected Canadian elected officials to the U.S. to “just counter as much disinformation as we possibly can and to try to hedge against what could be some very disastrous effects on Canada's economy.”

— Pundits sound off on the Cabinet huddle:

 From CTV’s "Question Period":

“It's an opportunity to start to craft that narrative that I think has been sorely lacking for the government heretofore.” — KORY TENEYCKE

“We've seen a lot of ill-discipline from Liberal MPs in the past week, and [Cabinet] can send the signal internally: This is the script. Start sticking to it.” — SCOTT REID

“Considering the disappointment that came out of the Charlottetown Cabinet retreat, it probably is that this one will have more meat on the bone. But what I've been looking for is, in terms of these announcements that they're rolling out, who are they targeting? It sounds like they're really targeting those election-rich areas of Toronto and Montreal.” — KATHLEEN MONK

From CBC’s Political Pulse panel:

“They're doing these little piecemeal things, but what is the overall, overarching narrative that they're going to push out?” — FRED DELOREY

”What I'm hoping that they're hearing, and what I was kind of hoping to see at the end of the year and the end-of-the-year interviews was some acknowledgement — a better way of showing Canadians that they're listening, that they're hearing the pain, the old Bill Clinton ‘I feel your pain.’” — GREG MACEACHERN of KAN Strategies

 “We're looking for more than just a narrative, a message coming out of it, but also acknowledgement that ‘Hey, we hear you. Times are tough.’ Unfortunately, I think we haven't really seen that.” — MÉLANIE RICHER

Republican presidential candidate Nikki Haley signs a baseball at a campaign event.

Republican presidential candidate Nikki Haley. | Jamie Kelter Davis for POLITICO

TRUMP’S THE WORD The 2024 race is heating up south of the border with 288 days until E-Day and just under a year now (!) until Inauguration Day, and the first primary right around the corner.

Trump is the favorite heading into Tuesday’s New Hampshire Republican primary, commanding a 19-point lead in one poll.

Former United States Ambassador to Canada BRUCE HEYMAN, who said he intends to work hard to get JOE BIDEN reelected, tells Playbook that if “red flashing lights and alarm bells aren't going off in Ottawa and Mexico City on the potential of a Trump administration, they should be.”

Playbook has been considering the hypothetical of what a round two of Trump running the U.S. would mean for Canada.

— Time to ‘batten down the hatches’: “Only your imagination is the limit to what is potential under a Trump administration pt. II,” Heyman warns. “He says the quiet part out loud, so if you don't think he's going to do radical things, you aren't listening to him at all.”

— Recall: Not so long ago, he notes, Trump threatened Canada with steel and aluminum tariffs on the basis of U.S. national security and shocked Canada’s auto industry with tariff threats.

— America, ‘first and alone’ in the world: Heyman says he’s “deeply concerned” about whether the scheduled 2026 USMCA trade agreement review would take place, given what Trump has said about Mexico, border walls and drug trafficking, and labor and environmental standards in the revised trade pact.

“He has used language about putting a tariff on all imports into the United States, and that will be a challenge under the existing NAFTA agreement. But if he immediately says it's not working, it might give him leeway to find pathways to putting that in place.”

 — Hit to institutions: “The multilateral organizations that we have been partners in together, putting NATO right at the top of that list, will be under Trump threat. Now the U.S. Congress has tried very hard to protect that with the last defense authorization, but I'm sure Donald Trump will find ways to revisit that issue.”

 — Message to Americans in Canada: Heyman said swing border states, such as Michigan and Wisconsin, could play a key role in determining the election.

“Americans who are living in Canada and concerned and horrified about the prospect of a Trump presidency—just being there and complaining on the sidelines is not going to be enough to be effective at all.”

— The flip side: But LOUISE BLAIS, former consul general in Atlanta in 2016, is not so worried. She told Playbook a Trump-wins scenario “may not be the end of the world for Canada,” pointing out Republicans normally tend to be “extremely” friendly to Canada.

“Trump 2 would not necessarily be all bad for Canada,” the former diplomat said, adding that she’s not advocating for any particular candidate.

She joined a long list of pundits who often point to the USMCA to say that, while the process was rocky, Canada ended up with a better deal in the end.

“I think Trump will not be focused on Canada,” she said. “He will have a lot of domestic issues that he'll want to get done, and so I think we just are less likely to see this kind of industrial policy that came out of the Biden presidency that was far sweeping, enormous and had an impact on Canada. Look at the amount of incentives that we've had to shell out to match the IRA [Inflation Reduction Act] in order to attract investments.”

— Flashback: Ottawa responded with some C$80 billion in clean tech tax credits — something CHRYSTIA FREELAND has noted wouldn’t have been as big were it not for the IRA. NAIMUL KARIM reflected on how the IRA has challenged and changed Canada back in August in the Financial Post.

— Trade bluster buster: Blais said it would be “really odd” for a president who has campaigned on the success of renegotiating the trade pact to “turn around and say, 'Well, it hasn't worked, so we're not going to renew,' because he is the author and signatory.”

“I think he understands that, but I could be wrong.”

ALL EYES ON TIFF — The Bank of Canada’s next rate and policy update is on the agenda for Wednesday. Pretty well no one expects the bank to dramatically shift to making cuts this week. — Tone-setting quote: “It’s far too early for the [central bank] to take a more dovish tone,” writes BMO macro economist BENJAMIN REITZES. “There’s no denying there’s been progress on bringing inflation lower; however, it’s also clear that there’s still plenty of work to do in order to get back to 2%.”

That means two other things will be under the microscope.

— Word of Gov: First, there will be intense interest in dissecting the words of central bank Governor TIFF MACKLEM, especially with respect to figuring out his timeline for rates.

CIBC Capital Markets’ deputy chief economist, BENJAMIN TAL, writes that one problem in evaluating where things are heading is that the number of inflation indicators the bank watches has ballooned over the years.

“At this point following any CPI release, the Bank and the market have to look at no less than 30 inflationary numbers to come up with a narrative,” he said in a lookahead note.

“The tone of Governor Macklem’s press conference will become increasingly more important than any new data releases because, at the end of the day, the Bank can always find an inflation number to fit its narrative.”

— The other watchword: The other thing keen observers will track is whether the bank will send signals on what it’s planning with its quantitative tightening program.

That’s a choice that could expose it to the political firing line.

“The Bank of Canada has been allowing the bonds it purchased during its quantitative easing (QE) program to mature and roll off its balance sheet. But since October, there have been some signs that policymakers might need to tap the brakes on [quantitative tightening],” ROYCE MENDES, Desjardins’ head of macro strategy, writes in a similar note.

“It would mean that the Bank of Canada’s purchases of Government of Canada bonds were not temporary after all, opening the institution up to criticism that it had financed the federal government’s massive COVID deficits.”

— Key numbers: Current interest rate: 5 percent. December inflation: 3.4 percent. Days from now until the next next rate update: 44.

Where the leaders are


— Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU is in Montreal for the Cabinet retreat.

— Deputy PM CHRYSTIA FREELAND is also attending the Cabinet shindig in Montreal.

— Conservative Leader PIERRE POILIEVRE holds a press conference in West Vancouver, B.C., at 12 p.m. EST.

— NDP Leader JAGMEET SINGH is in Edmonton and will kick off his party’s caucus retreat by going door knocking with Edmonton Centre candidate TRISHA ESTABROOKS and MPs HEATHER MCPHERSON and BLAKE DESJARLAIS.

2024 WATCH

An attendee holds a DeSantis 2024 sign in their lap at a campaign event at Bella Love Event Center in Ames, Iowa.

Florida's Ron DeSantis has bowed out of the race to lead the Republicans. | Jamie Kelter Davis for POLITICO

THE FIRST PRIMARY — RON DESANTIS is done. The Florida governor bowed out and endorsed DONALD TRUMP just two days ahead of the GOP New Hampshire primary, after suffering from dismal polling numbers in the state and placing a distant second in Iowa.

 — “At the end of the day, there was a lot of political malpractice,” GOP operative DENNIS LENNOX told POLITICO reporters KIMBERLY LEONARD, SALLY GOLDENBERG and GARY FINEOUT.

“Simply too many within his inner circle were either Tallahassee operatives with little national experience at the presidential level or they were part of the New Right Twitter chattering class and had little to no grounding outside their very insular and detached reality.”

MADISON FERNANDEZ writes for POLITICO that the air war in the early primary state already suggested the race was just between NIKKI HALEY and Trump. Haley also netted an endorsement from the influential Union Leader newspaper on Sunday.

Top of POLITICO this morning: Why DeSantis’ exit could hurt Haley in New Hampshire.

— Sure sure, Trump, but … While Trump has a commanding lead in New Hampshire, the race U.S. political watchers really care about right now is the one for vice president.

POLITICO’s ALEX ISENSTADT and MERIDITH MCGRAW tell us that those who decamped to the early voting state make up a veritable “who’s who of potential veeps”: Rep. ELISE STEFANIK of New York, Sen. J.D. VANCE of Ohio, Arizona U.S. Senate candidate KARI LAKE and Arkansas Gov. SARAH HUCKABEE SANDERS.

And that’s not even the full list of would-be VPs.

MEDIA ROOM


PETER ZIMONJIC writes for CBC News that politicians who are considering broadly targeting immigration to fix the housing unaffordability crisis may be in for a rude awakening.

— “What has happened to my country?” TARA HENLEY asked in a weekend essay over on The Hub. “How did we go from being a proudly pluralistic liberal democracy to a polarized nation that memory holes The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank and de-banks those who reject the party line?”

— On The Big Story pod this morning: The legal fight for the future of AI.

— National Post’s CHRIS SELLEY argues this should be JAGMEET SINGH’s moment, but he’s squandering it.

— “I like to complicate while everyone else is simplifying,” PAUL WELLS writes as he weighs in on Poilievre’s decision to pick a fight with the mayor of Montreal.

ALEX BOYD writes in the Toronto Star about those weird ads featuring SOPHIE GRÉGOIRE-TRUDEAU, MARY BERG and Canadian news organizations that are running rampant on social media.

PROZONE


For POLITICO Pro subscribers, our latest policy newsletter by SUE ALLAN: Davos and the dogs of war.

In other news for Pro readers:

EU puts on gloves for fight over economic security.

Washington takes aim at facial recognition.

Brussels puts outbound investment rules on the back burner.

Biden’s agencies are rethinking gas exports. Europe’s already feeling a chill.

Playbookers


Birthdays: HBD to former Conservative MP ERIN O’TOOLE, Liberal MP KEVIN LAMOUREUX, former NDP MP ANDREW CASH and retired Senator JIM COWAN.

Got a document to share? A birthday coming up? Send it all our way. 

Spotted: Sen. PAMELA WALLIN talking about her book, “Cats: True Tails and Life Lessons from a Purring Companion.”

Former Cabmin MARC GARNEAU making an exit from X.

On the weekend talk circuit, a demonstration of the curse of the elder millennial. On CTV’s "Question Period", DOMINIC LEBLANC referenced an immigration agreement with Quebec from the ‘90s and said, “You probably weren't born yet, Vassy, when that agreement was signed.” Host VASSY KAPELOS later retorted, “… and for the record, I was alive then, for at least 10 years.”

GCSurplus has an offer that would light up the hearts of any theater kids or MF Doom fans: one lot of 40 steel Roman masks.

Movers and shakers: Crestview Strategy just welcomed LUCAS BORCHENKO. 

In memoriam: NERENE VIRGIN, actor, journalist, social justice advocate, politician, has died. “She broke so many barriers consistently through her life," her nephew told CBC News. "She was rewriting the script on how a Black person can move through the world.”

Longtime Nova Scotia broadcaster FRANK CAMERON has died at 85, and is remembered as a lover of music and one of the good guys in the rough-and-tumble broadcasting business.

We're tracking every major political event of 2024 on a mega-calendar. Send us events and download the calendar yourself for Google and other clients .

ON THE HILL


The House of Commons is back Jan. 29; the Senate returns Feb. 6.

Find House committees here.

Keep track of Senate committees here.

Trivia


Friday’s answer: GORDON PINSENT played KEN TAYLOR in a 1981 movie-of-the-week about the escape of six Americans from Iran in January 1980.

Props to DUANE BRATT, DOUG SWEET, JULIE DEWOLFE, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, GEORGE SCHOENHOFER, SARA MAY, JIM CAMPBELL, RALPH LEVENSTEIN, NANCI WAUGH, GORDON RANDALL, MARCEL MARCOTTE, KEVIN COLBOURNE, MATT POIRIER, PATRICK DION, BOB GORDON, JOHN ECKER, JOHN MERRIMAN and KEVIN BOSCH.

Today’s question: Name the first president of the North American Life Assurance Company. Bonus question: How is that answer connected to this date in history?

Send your answer to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Playbook wouldn’t happen without: POLITICO Canada editor Sue Allan, editor Willa Plank and Luiza Ch. Savage.

Want to grab the attention of movers and shakers on Parliament Hill? Want your brand in front of a key audience of Ottawa influencers? Playbook can help. Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: jshapiro@politico.com.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Kyle Duggan @Kyle_Duggan

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post