Renewable siting leader out

Delivered every Monday by 10 a.m., New York & New Jersey Energy is your guide to the week’s top energy news and policy in Albany and Trenton.
May 28, 2024 View in browser
 
Weekly New York & New Jersey Energy newsletter logo.

By Marie J. French

Good morning and welcome to a special weekly Tuesday edition of the New York & New Jersey Energy newsletter. We'll take a look at the week ahead and look back on what you may have missed last week.

QUICK FIX

SITING OFFICE HEAD OUT: The head of the state’s permitting agency for renewable energy projects, who built the Office of Renewable Energy Siting from the ground up, has left as the Department of Public Service absorbs the office’s functions. Houtan Moaveni left ORES and will be replaced by Jessica Waldorf as interim executive director, the department announced on Friday. Waldorf is a top official at DPS as chief of staff and director of policy implementation.

This year’s state budget set up a major shakeup for the 4-year-old ORES, moving it from the Department of State under the umbrella of DPS. ORES will now also oversee transmission siting. Waldorf already oversees the DPS staff dealing with the previous renewable siting process and current transmission siting, as well as compliance with permits for projects.

“I have enormous confidence in Ms. Waldorf’s ability to establish the Office of Renewable Energy Siting within DPS and ensure all existing project applications continue to proceed apace,” said Public Service Commission Chair and DPS CEO Rory Christian in a statement. “I thank Houtan Moaveni for his service and for establishing a strong foundation from which the new ORES Office can grow.”

Christian said DPS would conduct a national search for a permanent executive director. Waldorf will establish ORES within the agency, integrate staff teams and spearhead development of the new transmission regulations.

Moaveni first took on a role as deputy executive director of ORES in 2020, shortly after the office was created under then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo. The goal of ORES was straightforward: get more renewables approved, faster, while still minimizing and mitigating environmental impacts. Renewable developers had complained for years about the Article 10 process slowing down progress.

Moaveni was previously the director of facility certification and compliance at DPS and prior to that was at NYSERDA working on solar siting and interconnection issues, including as a senior adviser to the president and an ombudsman for interconnecting distributed energy resources.

Under Moaveni’s leadership, ORES crafted uniform regulations for solar and wind projects and approved permits for 15 projects. The regulations stood up to a court challenge, as have the permits issued. Moaveni declined to comment on his departure. While ORES has complied with statutory deadlines for making decisions on projects, a recent audit from the comptroller faulted the office for a lengthy timeline to declare applications complete. The real timeline for a decision, from submission of an application, is more than three years, the audit found.

Moaveni had been scheduled to appear at a Senate Energy Committee hearing on May 15, but Christian appeared in his place. At the time, the DPS head indicated that work to integrate ORES was in the early stages with issues like e-mail addresses and office space being discussed. — Marie J. French

HAPPY TUESDAY MORNING: Let us know if you have tips, story ideas or life advice. We're always here at mfrench@politico.com and rrivard@politico.com. And if you like this letter, please tell a friend and/or loved one to sign up.

Want to receive this newsletter every weekday? Subscribe to POLITICO Pro. You’ll also receive daily policy news and other intelligence you need to act on the day’s biggest stories.

PSC MEMBER NOMINATION: Gov. Kathy Hochul has nominated a third woman to the state’s Public Service Commission, completing a transformation of the powerful utility regulator that plays a pivotal role in steering the state’s energy policy. Hochul nominated Radina Valova last week, according to two people familiar with the decision. POLITICO previously reported that she was a potential third nominee after Hochul sent nomination for two other women — Uchenna Bright and Denise Sheehan — with experience in the renewable energy policy space to the Senate.

Valova is regulatory vice president for the Interstate Renewable Energy Council and formerly worked as senior staff attorney and regulatory affairs manager for the Pace Energy and Climate Center. “This is an extremely exciting time to be a commissioner, and she’s got the issues in her wheelhouse,” said Karl Rábago, who was executive director of the Pace Center during much of Valova’s time there.

“She’s competent without being boastful; she’s experienced without being closed to new ideas,” he added, praising her intellectual curiosity and work engaging nonprofits in complex regulatory issues while at Pace. The commission has vast authority and responsibility to hit the state’s renewable energy and zero-emission electricity targets, as well as playing a pivotal role in the transition of the gas system to reduce emissions. The PSC is managing a tightrope between growing short-term costs for the state’s transition off fossil fuels and the future climate and health benefits.

Valova has written about some of these issues, co-authoring a 2020 report on the need to limit the growth of the gas system and transition homes off fossil fuels. At Pace, where she also got her law degree, she coordinated a coalition of nonprofit organizations to get involved in rate cases and also led involvement in “Reforming the Energy Vision” proceedings before the commission. At the Interstate Renewable Energy Council, Valova was charged with working to ensure policies to support distributed energy resources.

Valova’s nomination could be considered by the Senate as soon as this week, state Sen. Kevin Parker said.

Separately, however, Hochul is not expected to make a nomination for commissioner of the Department of Environmental Conservation before session ends, according to two people familiar with the discussions. That will leave interim Commissioner Sean Mahar in place as the department grapples with rolling out cap-and-invest draft regulations and a controversial decision on air permits to increase the amount of gas coming into New York via an existing pipeline. — Marie J. French

Here's what we're watching this week:

TUESDAY

— Parents bring their children to a rally with Assemblymembers Phara Souffrant Forrest and Emily Gallagher supporting the NY HEAT Act, 2 p.m., outside the Assembly, Capitol, Albany.

WEDNESDAY

— A climate youth rally and sit-in, starting with a presser at noon, outside the Assembly, Albany.

FRIDAY

— The Department of Public Service hosts a technical conference on the electric school bus transition, 1 p.m.

Around New York

— Senate Democrats want to lower the plastic reduction target in a proposed extended producer responsibility measure, Assemblymember Deborah Glick tells The New York Times.

— Water bill hike of 8.5 percent may be coming for New York City.

— Groundwater monitoring steps up in New York City.

— Lifeguards get new contract.

— The New York Times takes on e-bikes.

Around New Jersey

— Busy hurricane season ahead but flooding more of a concern.

What you may have missed

HOCHUL SIGNS SUFFOLK COUNTY WATER MEASURE: Gov. Kathy Hochul signed a measure to enable the Suffolk County Legislature to put a sales tax hike in front of voters in November to fund sewage infrastructure and septic systems. Hochul signed the bill (S8473/A8993) on Thursday, setting the stage for local action.

The effort fell short last year after passage of a state measure, with Suffolk County officials failing to reach a deal. That led to a local campaign issue as environmental groups worked to oust some county legislators over the water quality measure. Failing septic systems in Suffolk County threaten drinking water and local ecosystems due to nitrogen discharges. The 0.125 percent increase to the sales tax would raise about $6 billion through 2060, if approved by voters.

“Access to clean water is a basic need, and residents of Suffolk County deserve safe and reliable water infrastructure,” Hochul said in a statement. “I am committed to protecting the health of all New Yorkers, and this bill is a promise to future generations that we will do everything in our power to protect your well-being.”

Hochul’s swift action on the bill reflects the timeline needed to have the county approve the measure as well to ensure it makes the November ballot. — Marie J. French

COMMISSION REJECTS CON ED COST OVERRUN ASK: Con Edison spent millions more than planned on developing and testing a new customer billing and service system that went live in October last year. Some of the added costs came amid intense scrutiny of Central Hudson’s botched rollout of a new customer billing system, which led to the ouster of the utility’s CEO.

Con Ed exceeded the $455 million price cap set in its 2020 rate case for the project by $88 million. As utilities are wont to do, the company went to the Public Service Commission and asked to “capitalize” those costs, with an expectation that the utility would eventually seek to pass on the additional expense to ratepayers. But in a decision that passed without discussion at the commission’s meeting last week, the PSC rebuffed the request, holding the line on customer costs. In short, the PSC told Con Ed that customers should get the system they were promised at the agreed-on price.

“By imposing a cap on expenditures based on the utility’s own forecast, it encourages a utility to conduct thorough planning to develop an estimate it can achieve,” the order states. “This ensures that when a utility proposes a complex program, the Commission and other stakeholders can have confidence that the utility is presenting an estimate of costs and benefits the utility can deliver.”

Utilities are typically allowed to recoup costs for prudent expenses from their customers. But in this case, the commission stood by the cap set in the 2020 rate case. The order repeatedly scolds Con Ed for failing to raise the issue of higher costs in the pending rate case filed in 2022 and providing less detail than required as part of that process. “Con Edison failed to provide information with the level of detail traditionally provided in a rate case,” the order states. The order also notes the cap included a contingency of $35 million, which was fully utilized.

The utility attributed the added costs to more project complexity, implementation of “risk mitigation measure,” and resolving billing issues predating the new system. The commission order states that the company should have limited additional project features and included costs of testing to ensure a smooth rollout in initial estimates.

“A primary goal of the PSC is to protect ratepayers from bearing unlimited risk of poor cost estimation or project implementation by a utility. In this case, imposing a cap on expenditures based on Con Edison’s own forecast encourages a utility to conduct thorough planning to develop an estimate it can achieve,” said Department of Public Service spokesperson Jim Denn.

The utility could seek a rehearing of the order, or take other steps. “Con Edison is proud of the award-winning deployment of our upgraded customer service system, which is already providing significant new benefits to our customers and operations,” said spokesperson Jamie McShane. “We are reviewing the Commission’s order, along with our options related to the costs incurred to deliver this project.” — Marie J. French

ICYMI: POSITIVE POLLING FOR PLASTICS BILL: Raising bottle deposits from 5 cents to 10 cents was opposed 46 percent to 43 percent, a Siena College Research Institute poll released Wednesday found. Only 36 percent said they favored “state actions aimed at reducing fossil fuel use if those actions require you as a consumer to pay more for energy,” while 45 percent were opposed. But the “Packaging Reduction and Recycling Act” to reduce plastic waste was supported 67 percent to 22 percent. — Bill Mahoney

NYPA QUALIFIES RENEWABLE PARTNERS: The New York Power Authority has qualified 79 companies as part of its effort to build new renewable energy projects, in response to last year’s budget deal. The list of companies will be presented to the board of trustees at its Tuesday meeting.

The qualified partners include companies pitching pumped hydropower storage and green hydrogen, well-known land-based renewable developers, offshore wind and energy storage companies, investment firms and more. Companies can continue to apply to be qualified, and some may be eligible for other related requests for proposals in the future, according to NYPA.

The authority still has to develop a strategic plan, due at the beginning of 2025, before building any renewables. That plan should be released before public hearings this summer, NYPA president and CEO Justin Driscoll told POLITICO. He said there’s also ongoing engagement with stakeholders. “There won’t be shovels in the ground in 2024,” Driscoll said. “We're doing everything we can to put ourselves in the best position to be able to move quickly in 2025 and 2026.”

But having this list of partners will give NYPA the ability to act quickly once that process is complete. ”We don't want to have to go out and do a new solicitation for every project opportunity,” Driscoll said. “By having a pre-approved stable of vendors, we can then do mini-RFPs within that approved list, and we can go forward much quicker than we ordinarily would.” He said the authority expects to initially focus on “in flight” onshore solar and wind projects. “We’re going to focus on where we think we can move the needle quickest,” Driscoll said.

Vennela Yadhati, NYPA’s vice president of renewable project development who was brought on to head up this new line of business, said the authority would also build a pipeline of “greenfield” projects. But those wouldn’t be expected to come online until at least 2029, given the challenges of permitting and interconnecting projects.

The land-based renewables market in New York is currently facing massive uncertainty, as most of NYSERDA’s previously-awarded projects have canceled their contracts. Only 24 projects got tentative awards announced at the end of April, compared to 79 that have been canceled or withdrawn by developers since October 2023. NYSERDA has declined to disclose the tentative awardees or cost details, which it historically has released at this point in the process.

Several of the NYPA qualified companies have had NYSERDA contracts, with some operational projects. Well-known, established developers which previously had most of the onshore projects under contract on the list include EDF Renewables, NextEra, Repsol (which acquired ConnectGen’s portfolio), Boralex, Invenergy and Hecate. Driscoll said NYPA would likely seek NYSERDA contracts for qualified new renewables, although he did not rule out other arrangements to support projects. The authority also pre-qualified some investors in renewables, including D.E. Shaw and a pension fund, as potential partners. The legislation authorizing NYPA to build and own renewables requires the authority to retain a 51 percent stake in projects.

“The idea is how do we amplify NYPA’s time, resources and capital to maximize the impact,” Yadhati said. “That can be either co-development or co-investment if that's going to significantly multiply what we're putting in. That's what we're aiming for: to bring more capacity and more megawatts online.”

Companies with offshore wind interests, including Orsted, RWE and EDP Renewables also qualified. Driscoll said NYPA hasn’t ruled out anything related to offshore wind. Several energy storage developers including Key Capture Energy were also listed. Yadhati said early opportunities would be for co-located, hybrid energy storage and renewables, but that NYPA could also play a role in responding to future NYSERDA solicitations for storage. — Marie J. French

 

Follow us on Twitter

Marie J. French @m_jfrench

Ry Rivard @ryrivard

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post