New York’s nastiest House race

Presented by Uber: POLITICO's must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers
Oct 11, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO Newsletter Header

By Emily Ngo, Nick Reisman and Jeff Coltin

Presented by 

Uber

With Timmy Facciola

Marc Molinaro is pictured during an event.

The face-off also touched on the debunked rumor amplified by former President Donald Trump and his running mate JD Vance that Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio, eat their pets. | Mary Altaffer/AP

New York Playbook is off Monday. We'll be back in your inboxes on Tuesday.

It took mere minutes Thursday night at their first and likely only debate for Rep. Marc Molinaro and Josh Riley to literally turn on each other and begin talking over each other.

The pattern repeated itself so often and the rancor was so palpable that moderator Mark Mulholland of NewsChannel 13 insisted thrice throughout the hour that the bitter upstate rivals remember the viewers — or fight on their own time.

Molinaro, a first-term Republican, and Riley, his Democrat challenger, accused each other again and again of lying.

Welcome to New York’s nastiest House race.

Central to the debate — as it is to their very expensive rematch in NY-19 — was border security.

Molinaro, one of the nation’s most vulnerable House Republicans, has sought to pin blame on Riley for illegal immigration and crime associated with it. Riley as an attorney has boosted DACA, opposed the so-called Muslim ban and argued for resources to be focused on the highest-threat arrivals.

“This president used the ‘prosecutorial discretion’ argument that you made to catch-and-release. And then they come to New York, where there’s a sanctuary state because of your allies, Kathy Hochul and others,” Molinaro told Riley, ultimately declining to answer the moderator’s question on whether he stands by attack ads from him and allied groups.

“He is a 30-year career politician who is desperate, desperate to talk about anything other than his record of failure on this issue, so desperate to the point that he’s literally just making things up,” Riley responded. “Every one of those incidents that he’s talking about and putting on TV, that happened on his watch; he’s in Congress.”

The candidates did change tack a bit when it came to questions on abortion. Rather than face Riley, Molinaro looked into the camera to speak directly to voters.

“I have witnessed the millions of dollars that my opponent used to lie about my record and my belief,” he said. “I oppose a national ban, and I remain committed to opposing a national ban.”

Riley also looked straight at viewers when he said, “He’s lying to you. … Women’s health care decisions are women’s health care decisions, and politicians like Mark Molinaro can stay the hell out of it.”

The face-off, the most heated of the battleground debates thus far, also touched on the debunked rumor amplified by former President Donald Trump and his running mate JD Vance that Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio, eat their pets.

Molinaro did not recant or apologize for his part in spreading the rumor on social media.

“I certainly respect those who want to come to this nation legally,” he said. “But I will not back down in making the argument that because of the policies of this administration, we are less safe at our southern border.”

Riley, meanwhile, repeated that he is critical of how both parties have failed to secure the border. — Emily Ngo

HAPPY FRIDAY: Let’s go Yanks! Got news? Send it our way: Jeff Coltin, Emily Ngo and Nick Reisman.

 

A message from Uber:

New York City Uber riders pay $700 Million in taxes and fees annually* That’s more than the entire budget for New York City Parks Department. *Based on trips originating from NYC in 2023. Learn more.

 

WHERE’S KATHY? Making AI-related and housing announcements in Buffalo and speaking at the NAACP New York State Conference’s 88th annual convention in Armonk.

WHERE’S ERIC? Calling into GMGT LIVE’s “The Reset Talk Show” and hosting a roundtable discussion with Brooklyn African American community leaders.

QUOTE OF THE DAY: “There are people, shady people, who will try to manipulate the [casino bidding] process to their benefit and be willing to put out lies. I have had no intention of putting this in my executive budget.” — Gov. Kathy Hochul, denying a New York Post report that she would help ease the way for donor Steve Cohen’s casino bid, via the Post.

ABOVE THE FOLD

New York Attorney General Tish James speaks at a rally.

This foray to Pennsylvania is the latest stop by Attorney General Tish James in a must-win state for Democrats. | Jason DeCrow/AP

FIRST IN PLAYBOOK: Attorney General Letitia James is heading back to a battleground state.

James, listed as a special guest, will be in Pennsylvania today to attend a breakfast rally for the Harris-Walz ticket, according to an invitation to the event obtained by Playbook.

The Philadelphia breakfast will feature Sen. Bob Casey, a Democrat locked in a competitive reelection battle against Republican David McCormick, and Black clergy members.

This foray to Pennsylvania is the latest stop by James in a must-win state for Democrats.

Last weekend, James traveled to Michigan for a weekend of campaigning that included stumping with the state’s Democratic attorney general, Dana Nessel.

These trips come as James has gained a national platform after winning a $450 million civil judgment against Trump, which he is appealing. — Nick Reisman 

CITY HALL: THE LATEST

Bill de Blasio speaks into a microphone while pointing right finger.

Despite his supportive comments, former Mayor Bill de Blasio criticized Adams’ inner circle. | Charlie Neibergall/AP

MAYOR-ON-MAYOR: Mayor Eric Adams doesn’t have too many people rushing to his defense these days, as his team racks up raids, phone seizures and — in his case — a criminal indictment.

But he has something of a sympathizer in his predecessor, fellow Democrat Bill de Blasio, who faced his own lengthy federal investigation. (Prosecutors cleared de Blasio, and he went on to win reelection.)

“Innocent until proven guilty is a real thing,” de Blasio said during a conversation Thursday night with Betsy Fischer Martin, executive director of American University’s Women & Politics Institute. “I have plenty of questions here — real questions about what has happened in the Adams administration and the meaning of these charges and what’s happening with a number of his colleagues.”

During the one-on-one at Harvard Kennedy School’s Institute of Politics, de Blasio took a shot at the strength of the charges brought forth against Adams last month from the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York.

“I don’t personally find the charges to be that powerful based on what I’ve seen. They seem a little diffuse to me,” said the former mayor, who quietly helped Adams in the 2021 mayoral primary. He added that prosecutors have been “leaking” information to build their case, which centers around allegations Adams accepted bribes from Turkish officials in exchange for official favors.

Despite his supportive comments, de Blasio criticized Adams’ inner circle — many of whom have been fired or resigned amid an ever-growing list of city and federal probes. And he questioned the morality of taking gifts in the form of flight upgrades, which prosecutors allege Adams did.

He also advised Adams to “stop sounding like a victim” and focus on delivering for constituents.

The former mayor — whose hopes for advancing his political career were dashed by dismal approval ratings — also threw cold water on ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s interest in running for mayor, saying his longtime rival “basically wanted the state to himself.” Sally Goldenberg

IN THE ZONE: “It sends a shiver up your spine,” City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams said while touring the new “Undesign the Red Line” exhibit in City Hall Thursday.

Will the City of Yes for Housing plan — which is being negotiated and voted on by her council now — help fix the legacy of exclusionary zoning and housing discrimination?

“My main thing with this is affordability,” Adams responded. “Who can afford to live here at the end of the day?”

Council members Shahana Hanif and Kevin Riley also toured the exhibit Thursday, which the mayor’s administration set up this week to bolster their argument the housing plan addresses racial iniquities. — Jeff Coltin

PATH FORWARD: At the Times Square subway station Thursday, Mayor Adams announced a pilot program to conduct overnight homeless outreach throughout Manhattan subway stops this winter.

“As the weather changes, many people start to use the subway system as their primary place of housing,” Adams said. “That needs to change.”

The program – dubbed Partnership Assistance for Transit Homelessness, or PATH for short – will deploy teams of one nurse, two service coordinators and four transit officers to offer services ranging from shelter placement to wound care.

Adams said the program has been operating since Aug. 29. In that time, teams have made contact with 1,500 homeless people and delivered services to 500.

“We are saying in no way that people who are dealing with these needs should be in jail, just the opposite. They don’t deserve to be ignored either,” Adams said.

Standing next to the mayor was interim Police Commissioner Tom Donlon, who cleaned out his office Thursday and plans to step down, POLITICO first reported. Donlon did not answer questions about his departure. — Timmy Facciola

BILLS TO IMPROVE CONTRACTING: The City Council passed three bills Thursday intended to reform the city’s contracting process, legislation which sponsor Julia Won described as especially essential as the Adams administration is under investigation for some of its contracts.

News coverage of alleged corruption has “revealed the Adams Administration’s waste of millions of taxpayer dollars in questionable contracts,” Won, a Queens council member, said, adding that her legislation would help “bring transparency, accountability, and fairness” to contracting. The bills address subcontractors and food procurement vendors.

Adams' spokesperson Liz Garcia said the mayor’s office was glad to have worked with Won on the bills, which “formalize current agency practices and provide greater certainty to vendors and subcontractors.” But Garcia did not respond when asked whether Adams would sign them into law. — Emily Ngo

CITY MONEY: Mayoral hopeful Brad Lander brought in $316,000 worth of donations in the last three months — and should already be eligible for $3.5 million in public matching funds overall, his campaign told Playbook ahead of Friday’s filing deadline.

This was Lander’s biggest fundraising period yet — with his pace picking up significantly after announcing plans to run for mayor, instead of reelection as comptroller. — Jeff Coltin

More from the city:

FBI agents raided the NYPD’s School Safety Division headquarters in Queens as part of a probe into city contracts. (New York Post)

Former top Adams adviser Tim Pearson’s nephew, who was promoted to detective with just two arrests in his four-year career, has been placed on desk duty. (Daily News)

The judge presiding over Adams’ campaign corruption case has dedicated much of his career to defending fair elections. (Gothamist)

 

A message from Uber:

Advertisement Image

 
NEW FROM PLANET ALBANY

Rep. Pat Ryan and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez at a press conference

Assemblymember Sarahana Shrestha spoke to Playbook at a recent campaign event with Reps. Pat Ryan and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. | Jason Beeferman/POLITICO

OUT OF SIGHT, OUT OF MIND: Federal politics are a bit too far removed for this state legislator.

“I know very little about Congress, I’ll be honest,” Assemblymember Sarahana Shrestha told Playbook on Thursday while attending an event featuring Democratic Reps. Pat Ryan and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in her Kingston district.

Shrestha, who in 2022 became the first upstate lawmaker to be endorsed by the Democratic Socialists of America in decades, was asked whether she approved of the job Ryan — who represents much of her district — was doing in Congress after the event.

She said she wasn’t able to answer the question because, for the most part, she hasn’t been paying attention to what’s happening at the federal level.

“To be honest, this is my second year as the assemblymember, so I have been deep in the state Legislature,” she said. “I’m learning the ropes, and we get tossed into the budget fight; we get tossed into the bills we’re trying to pass. So I will be honest, I have not been paying attention to a lot of the federal politics.”

“I don’t know what is happening on the transportation front at the federal level; I don’t know what’s really happening at the healthcare level, at the unemployment benefits level,” she added. “I’m just like, we have to pass things here, so I have no idea.”

Shrestha was then asked if she planned on voting for Ryan.

“Yes, of course,” she said. “Working Families Party all the way.” — Jason Beeferman

WELCOME TO NY: While some Democrats, like Sen. Brad Hoylman-Sigal, may be dreading the idea of Trump holding a rally at Madison Square Garden, Hochul is sardonically in favor of it.

Hochul told reporters Thursday she thinks it’s surprising Trump is in deep blue New York and not swing states with less than a month to go before Election Day.

“If I was advising him, which I’d never do, those might seem more lucrative places to spend your time,” she said. “But come to New York, spend some money, help our tax base. It will have no effect here. It will have zero effect on New York.”

Trump’s visit to New York may not give him a leg up in the Electoral College. But the state is home to a handful of swing House seats that could determine control of the chamber next year.

Hochul, who has been leading an effort to flip GOP-held seats in the state, said she has been “laser-focused” on building out the infrastructure for down-ballot campaigns.

“I believe that Democrats are the ones who will lead us forward and not to that dark place Donald Trump and MAGA Republicans are leading us to,” she said. — Nick Reisman

More from Albany:

A state panel is leaning toward raising pay for state agency heads. (POLITICO Pro)

Hochul is being urged to send state troopers to a troubled part of Queens. (New York Post)

Republicans want the governor to delay the implementation of zero-emissions standards. (Buffalo News)

KEEPING UP WITH THE DELEGATION

Rep. Anthony D'Esposito (R-N.Y.) speaks at the U.S. Capitol on Sept. 11, 2024.

Rep. Anthony D'Esposito is being very picky about which Democratic leaders he's criticizing. | Bonnie Cash/Getty Images

ADAMS ADS? NOT ON INDICTMENT: Only three new GOP TV ads in New York House battlegrounds have featured Adams since his historic Sept. 27 criminal arraignment, and none have referenced his fraud and bribery charges.

The latest, released Thursday by Rep. Anthony D’Esposito to champion the Republican as the candidate for public safety, mentions the mayor, but doesn’t use his image as other attack ads have.

“Adams, Hochul, Biden: They ruined New York,” a man says in the 30-second spot called “Say No on Radical.” D’Esposito faces Democrat Laura Gillen on Long Island.

Why no direct hits on Adams’ legal woes? Any GOP attack focused on his indictment would invite unwelcome questions about Trump’s conviction and other charges, POLITICO reports.

The mayor remains deeply unpopular in swing districts, with his approval rating plummeting to an average 9 percent, according to internal NRCC polling obtained by POLITICO. But Republicans are finding he’s a better bogeyman on crime, unchecked immigration and what they said is rampant corruption among Democrats. — Emily Ngo

BRAGGING ABOUT BIPARTISANSHIP: Appeal across the aisle is the name of the game in the battleground House races, and two candidates this week touted smaller endorsements that they say reinforce their bipartisanship.

Republican Alison Esposito’s bid for Congress in the Hudson Valley was endorsed by the New Era Democrats. They’re centrist Democrats who once endorsed de Blasio for mayor, yes, but they’re also based in Brooklyn and backed Esposito’s former running mate Lee Zeldin for governor.

Democrat John Avlon got a nod from the Coram Civic Association on Long Island, which at the same time endorsed Donald Trump for its slate. The local group had said candidates who didn’t participate in their event wouldn’t be considered — with Trump as an exception — and incumbent Rep. Nick LaLota was in Washington that night.

This cycle, some of the highest-profile endorsements signaling contenders’ bipartisan appeal have been the Nassau County PBA for Democratic Rep. Tom Suozzi and the Teamsters and Transport Workers Union for Republican Rep. Mike Lawler. Esposito’s rival, Democratic Rep. Pat Ryan, was endorsed by the New York City Deputy Sheriffs’ Association, and LaLota’s nods include TWU and other labor unions. — Emily Ngo

NEW YORK STATE OF MIND

The chief executive of an Amsterdam, New York company set off a debate by displaying his support for Trump in a 100-foot-wide sign atop his headquarters. (New York Times)

The shuttered College of Saint Rose has filed for bankruptcy. (Times Union)

A temporary restraining order blocked the Department of Transportation from starting work on the $1 billion Kensington Expressway project in Buffalo. (Spectrum News)

 

A message from Uber:

Ever thought about what it’s like to drive for Uber in New York?

Uber Drivers earn $32 per hour.* And that’s before incentives and tips

They also get benefits including dental insurance, vision coverage, mental health support, and workers’ compensation through the Black Car Fund and Driver Benefits Fund.

*Average earnings per online hour from January - July 2024 based on trips originating from NYC

Learn more.

 
SOCIAL DATA

Edited by Daniel Lippman

MAKING MOVES: Anuradha Hebbar has been appointed as the president of CEO Action for Inclusion & Diversity.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY: Tishman Speyer’s Rob Speyer … Geto & de Milly’s Christopher Johnson … WSJ’s Tarini PartiJamie Weinstein(WAS THURSDAY): Bruce Karsh ... Avi Davidoff (IS SATURDAY): Tusk’s Chris Coffey … Assemblymember Karines Reyes … NYC Council Member Robert Holden … NYSUT’s Melinda Person NYT’s Michael Barbaro (IS SATURDAY): Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez(IS MONDAY): NYC Council Member Justin Brannan … Moonshot’s Jenny SedlisFrank Seddio

Missed Thursday’s New York Playbook PM? We forgive you. Read it here.

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post