Prop 1 continues to be a problem for Dems

Presented by Amazon: Your afternoon must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers
Nov 05, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO Newsletter Header

By Jason Beeferman

Presented by 

Amazon

Democratic Congressional candidate Laura Gillen casting her ballot in Nassau County.

Democratic Congressional candidate Laura Gillen casting her ballot in Nassau County, moments before she refused to answer how she voted on Proposal 1. | Jason Beeferman/POLITICO

Democratic congressional candidate Laura Gillen has made abortion rights a central issue of her campaign.

But when Playbook asked her how she voted on ballot proposal 1 — the Democrat-backed effort to enshrine abortion rights into the state constitution — Gillen ignored the question.

Then she ignored it eight more times.

“Have a great day,” she said, putting her head down and swiftly walking away as reporters continued to ask how she voted.

The moment served as an encapsulation of just how fraught the effort to enshrine abortion rights in true-blue New York has become.

Once thought to be a boon that would drive voter turnout for Democrats, the vaguely worded amendment was co-opted by Republicans who sought to turn it into a referendum on trans athletes' participation on sports teams.

Now, Prop 1 appears to be a liability for Democrats on Election Day — especially in one of the state’s most competitive House districts where control of Congress hangs in the balance.

“Laura Gillen continues to try and hide her leftist values that are wildly out of step with Long Islanders like her support for men playing in girl’s sports, which is in strong contrast with Congressman D’Esposito who has been clear about his opposition to Proposition 1 since day one,” Matt Capp, a spokesperson for Gillen’s opponent, Republican Anthony D’Esposito, told Playbook in a statement.

The language of the ballot proposal — which was the subject of its own controversy — does not include the word “abortion” but would add “anti-discrimination provisions” to the state constitution that address “reproductive healthcare and autonomy” and “gender identity and pregnancy.”

Gillen’s campaign issued a statement to Playbook after she dodged questions, saying she backed the measure, but it did not outright confirm how she voted.

“I support measures that protect women’s reproductive freedoms — including Prop 1 — while my opponent has repeatedly voted to rip away women’s abortion rights,” Gillen said.

New Yorkers for Equal Rights, which runs the campaign to pass Prop 1, declined to comment on the story.

The campaign, spearheaded by its director Sasha Ahuja, came under scrutiny after a POLITICO report revealed the effort had become a cash cow for polling and consultant firms. As of the start of October, organizers of the measure had spent less than 16 percent of funds on direct voter outreach.

Since then, they’ve spent millions in the final days before Election Day on advertising and other direct voter outreach. Gov. Kathy Hochul also hosted rallies to boost the ballot proposal as the state Democratic party swooped in to assist with outreach and an additional $2 million in cash.

Hochul, through the state party’s Coordinated Campaign effort, has also injected Democratic volunteers and resources into Gillen’s race.

It wasn’t as if Gillen didn’t want reporters at the polls with her today — she had invited the press to take pictures of her voting and planned to answer questions outside the site.

While speaking with reporters, she identified “protecting reproductive freedom” as one of her winning issues.

The state party is already bracing for a poor showing for the amendment.

“I don’t think it will be reflective of the support that abortion rights have in the state of New York because, unfortunately, due to the way it was written, voters simply can’t understand it and Republicans can try to misconstrue it,” New York Democratic Committee Chair Jay Jacobs told Playbook on Monday. — Jason Beeferman

 

A message from Amazon:

Advertisement Image

 
AT THE BALLOT BOX

Elections worker sorts ballots at City Hall in San Francisco.

Ballots being counted in California. In Queens, voting machines were malfunctioning today after some machines did not accept ballots during voters' initial attempts to submit them. | Jeff Chiu/AP

BALLOT ISSUES IN QUEENS: Across the World’s Borough, ballot scanner malfunctions were being reported at various polling places.

Vincent Ignizio, deputy executive director of the New York City Board of Elections, said scanners have been “kicking out” ballots, forcing voters to input them multiple times before the machine accepts them.

The issue caused delays across polling places and required Ignizio and the Board of Elections to dispatch technicians to sites across the borough.

It also serves as a small, but serious example of ballot counting issues in a process already fraught with accusations of fraud from Republicans nationally.

Former President Donald Trump, whose claims of fraud spurred the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol, has already laid the groundwork to contest this year’s election results.

Tony Nunziato, who leads the Queens GOP, said he’d been getting reports of machines rejecting ballots “10-15 times” with some residents reporting machines not working at all.

“Of course it’s frustrating,” he said. “We’re at the brink of something that’s monumental for the United States and we should have easy voting. They should be able to process it fast and get out, there shouldn't be any problems.”

Multiple reports of machines also malfunctioning in Brooklyn were dismissed by Ignizio.

“We have recorded votes from all poll sites in Bklyn. So that’s not accurate,” he said in a text to Playbook.

In a separate statement, the Board of Elections reassured New Yorkers that all votes are being counted.

“Technicians were immediately dispatched, and corrective measures were undertaken,” the board said. “In an abundance of caution, we had all 290 sites in Queens inspected. Voters are voting and have been voting all day. Voters have not been impacted beyond additional attempts to scan their ballot or have it placed in the emergency bin as is protocol. We want to assure the public; any ballot cast will be counted.” — Jason Beeferman

DOWN BALLOT

Jonathan Rinaldi was spotted being taken into this unmarked NYPD car, according to eyewitnesses at the scene

Jonathan Rinaldi was spotted being taken into this unmarked NYPD car, according to eyewitnesses at the scene. | Provided

QUEENS CANDIDATE ARRESTED: A longshot Republican Assembly candidate in Queens was arrested outside a poll site today and charged with harassment after calling volunteers supporting Prop 1 “baby killers.”

Jonathan Rinaldi was given “numerous commands” by police officers “to stop screaming and yelling outside the poll site. He refused,” a police department spokesperson told Playbook. Rinaldi was released with a summons and returned to P.S. 101 in Forest Hills to keep campaigning.

Around 10:30 a.m., Rinaldi was campaigning near a table of Working Families Party volunteers canvassing for Prop 1, which is meant to enshrine protections for abortion in the state constitution. He began inching closer “and he started calling us baby killers, because of Prop 1,” WFP volunteer Gladys Sandoval told Playbook. Rinaldi refused to move away when they asked him to, swung his campaign sign and started cursing. When the volunteers brought over a police officer, he refused their orders and was arrested, Sandoval said.

“I said Proposition 1 is going to kill babies,” Rinaldi said to Playbook. He denied harassing the volunteers, saying it was “First Amendment protected activity” and that the WFP volunteers had a political opponent arrested for speech. He said he plans to sue for what he called “election interference.”

Rinaldi has routinely been accused of harassment by other elected officials, City & State reported , leading some to boost security at their offices out of fear of him. He is challenging Democratic Assemblymember Andrew Hevesi, but it’s not expected to be a competitive race.

Rinaldi’s argument with an NYPD supervisor Tuesday while in handcuffs was filmed by his supporter David Rem, who spoke at Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally and called Harris “the antichrist.” Jeff Coltin

THE PRESIDENTIAL: Republicans believe Rep. Brandon Williams in central New York could have the toughest night.

The boundaries of the first-term lawmaker’s Syracuse-area district were redrawn to be slightly more favorable to Democratic candidate John Mannion.

And a surge in votes for Trump is unlikely to help him, said Conservative Party Chair Gerard Kassar. His reasoning: A Trump boost at the ballot box will likely be canceled out by votes for Harris.

“The Trump factor there is much more neutral,” Kassar said. “Brandon’s district I think will come down to him versus Mannion.”

Still, Kassar expects Williams can put points on the board against Mannion, who Republicans have linked to Gov. Kathy Hochul and unpopular policies in Albany like left-leaning criminal justice law changes.

But Williams in recent days has hit some potholes, including House Speaker Mike Johnson initially saying Republicans would try to repeal the CHIPS and Science Act, a vehicle for Micron Technology to build a massive factory in the Syracuse area.

Johnson later walked those comments back, but Democrats believe the damage to Williams was done. Nick Reisman

 

A message from Amazon:

Advertisement Image

 
From The Campaign Trail

Voting in Rockland County

At least one voter in Rockland County casted their ballot for Anthony Frascone, a candidate for congress appearing on the Working Families Party ballot line. | Katelyn Cordero/POLITICO

SPOILER ALERT: The mysterious move to install Anthony Frascone as the Working Families Party nominee in New York’s 17th congressional race may prove fruitful afterall.

“I voted for the other guy. There was a third one,” said Sleepy Hollow resident Mark Clark, who told Playbook he viewed Frascone as the “underdog.”

Playbook confirmed that at least one voter in the district cast his ballot for Frascone, but it wasn’t clear if he knew why.

“I kind of like his message he was trying to get out,” Clark told Playbook. “He came up [when] I was just reading on Google.”

Frascone’s campaign does not have a website, issues page, or social media presence.

Clark was unphased when he learned that some people suspect Frascone is running just to spoil the race for Democratic hopeful Mondaire Jones. “We need a third party,” he said in response.

Frascone was able to wiggle onto the ballot in June when WFP removed its financial support for Jones after he endorsed Rep. Jamaal Bowman's opponent in the Democratic primary. Frascone ran in June against Jones in the Working Families Party primary and mustered enough votes to win the ballot line. — Timmy Facciola

IN OTHER NEWS...

CAR CRASHES INTO POLLING SITE: A car crashed into an Ithaca polling site in what appeared to be an accident. (Ithaca Times)

MONDAIRE’S FRIENDS: Democratic congressional candidate Mondaire Jones will have few allies in congress if he is elected today. (Gothamist)

A DOGGED CAMPAIGN: The race for NYC Dog Mayor has gotten ruff amid accusations that crypto bros are buying votes. (New York Post)

Missed this morning’s New York Playbook? We forgive you. Read it here.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Jason Beeferman @JasonBeeferman

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post