Scaled-back City of Yes clears Council

Presented by Uber: POLITICO's must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers
Dec 06, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO Newsletter Header

By Janaki Chadha, Emily Ngo, Jeff Coltin and Nick Reisman

Presented by 

Uber

With Timmy Facciola

A man in a blue suit and blur and white striped tie stands at a podium and holds a sign that says "City of Yes"

Mayor Eric Adams wanted to eliminate parking mandates citywide and legalize basement apartments and backyard cottages across the five boroughs. | Ed Reed/Mayoral Photography Office.

After $5 billion was added and 20,000 homes nixed from Mayor Eric Adams' City of Yes housing plan, more than a third of the City Council still voted no to more development.

That includes members whose districts were carved out of some of the most controversial provisions of the mayor’s hotly debated blueprint, which cleared a full council vote Thursday.

Mayor Adams wanted to eliminate parking mandates citywide and legalize basement apartments and backyard cottages across the five boroughs. Those provisions and some others were scaled back in the largely suburban-style neighborhoods where they faced the fiercest opposition.

That wasn’t enough to convince council members like Linda Lee or Eric Dinowitz, who represent low-slung sections of outer Queens and the Bronx, respectively. Both their districts retained parking requirements in some form, and changes allowing apartment buildings near train stations were narrowed. Swaths of Lee’s district were also exempted from a provision legalizing backyard apartments.

“While the most recent amendments to the City of Yes have alleviated some of my most dire concerns, there still remains issues that can significantly impact my parts of Queens,” said Lee, who represents neighborhoods including Fresh Meadows and Bayside. The plan, she added, “will place further strain on areas that are not fit for additional density.”

Other members who voted against the plan despite changes limiting the impact in their districts include Kamillah Hanks, Jim Gennaro and Chris Banks.

That’s not to mention the plan’s most vocal opponents, like Vickie Paladino and Bob Holden who for the duration of the debate seemed unlikely to be swayed even if there were changes to the plan. Their fellow members of the council’s bipartisan Common Sense Caucus all voted against the plan as well.

Still, the changes were essential to winning over key members on the margins, like Selvena Brooks-Powers and Nantasha Williams, who both represent parts of southeast Queens.

“These concessions were important to get me to where I am today,” Brooks-Powers said during the vote.

And as far as zoning modifications go, officials could not have offered member-specific carve-outs – for example, offering concessions on parking mandates to Brooks-Powers but not other members who represent similar types of districts – without opening the plan up to legal issues.

Speaker Adrienne Adams stressed the plan preserved the character of the city’s neighborhoods while still enacting critical reforms to address a worsening housing shortage.

“This is not the proposal that was delivered to us as some of my colleagues have presented,” she said Thursday, emphasizing the changes. “This cannot be the council that turns their back and continues to say, scrap it, let’s move ahead, let’s do something else because I tell you, that will never happen.” — Janaki Chadha

HAPPY FRIDAY: Got news? Send it our way: Jeff Coltin, Emily Ngo and Nick Reisman.

 

A message from Uber:

Study Reveals Uber Drivers Make More than EMTs: NYC Uber drivers now earn an average of $52,900 annually after expenses, outpacing the salaries of many essential city employees, including EMTs and sanitation workers. Despite delivering vital services, these workers struggle with stagnant wages while Uber drivers have benefited from five TLC-mandated pay hikes since 2020. Read more on the wage disparity impacting NYC’s workforce. Learn More.

 

WHERE’S KATHY? In New York City and California with no public schedule.

WHERE’S ERIC? Conducting a series of interviews following the passage of his “City of Yes” and later delivering remarks at a flag-raising ceremony for Lebanon.

QUOTE OF THE DAY: “Hands down Ed Koch … He was the perfect New York politician. Sleeves rolled up, sweating, yelling at people.” — Comedian and Harvey Epstein impersonator John Mulaney, when Vulture asked “Saturday Night Live” stars about the best New York City mayor.

ABOVE THE FOLD

Adrienne Adams speaks next to Eric Adams.

“I repeatedly said that we have no plans to change the law as it stands right now,” Council Speaker Adrienne Adams told reporters Thursday. | Emil Cohen/NYC Council Media Unit

SANCTUARY CITY STANDOFF: Mayor Adams is reiterating he wants to loosen New York City’s sanctuary city laws. The City Council is reminding him they’re having none of it.

“I repeatedly said that we have no plans to change the law as it stands right now,” Council Speaker Adrienne Adams told reporters Thursday.

The speaker, no relation to the mayor, also sought to clarify the policies restricting local law enforcement’s cooperation with federal immigration authorities: They’re not meant to protect individuals convicted of serious and violent crimes.

“The administration has to be clear and accurate when discussing city law — and ensure that they abide by it instead of stoking fear and spreading misinformation,” she said.

The mayor on Tuesday implied non-citizens in the country don’t have the right to due process — even though they do.

“The Constitution is for Americans, and I’m not a person that snuck into this country,” he told reporters earlier this week. “What rights I have, the person that decides to shoot the police officer, they should not have those same rights.”

Adams said he’ll uphold sanctuary city laws, including those beefed up under former Mayor Bill de Blasio. But he’s made it known he’s not happy about it.

The mayor also has said he wants undocumented immigrants who “commit” serious crimes deported, though the standard now for deportation is conviction.

“I have not been silent on my feeling for those who commit serious crimes in our city and those who are repeated offenders in our city, particularly violent crimes,” the mayor told MSNBC on Thursday. “We’re not talking about those who steal an apple.”

He said he will meet with Trump’s pick for border czar on Thursday.

While Speaker Adams and much of the City Council want sanctuary city laws to stay as they are, not all on the legislative body feel the same.

Council Member Bob Holden, a centrist Democrat representing Queens, wants ICE back at the Rikers Island jail complex. — Emily Ngo

 

REGISTER NOW: As the 118th Congress ends, major decisions loom, including healthcare appropriations. Key focus: site neutrality. Can aligning hospital and clinic costs cut federal spending, reflect physician costs, and lower patient expenses? Join policymakers and providers to discuss.

 
 
CITY HALL: THE LATEST

New York City mayoral candidates Zohran Mamdani, Brad Lander, Scott Stringer and Jessica Ramos sit on stage at a mayoral candidate forum on the future of human services.

New York City mayoral candidates Zohran Mamdani, Brad Lander, Scott Stringer and Jessica Ramos attend a mayoral candidate forum on the future of human services on Dec. 5, 2024. | Jeff Coltin/POLITICO

DOLLAR DOLLAR BILL Y’ALL: Paying nonprofit city contractors on time is the hottest issue of the 2025 elections — at least for the moment.

“It’s definitely the worst it’s ever been,” Human Services Council CEO Michelle Jackson told THE CITY last week, with 90 percent of her organization’s members saying they’ve had delayed payments – and one-third of those getting delayed for more than six months.

Every single candidate talked about fixing the problem at a mayoral candidate forum co-hosted by HSC Thursday morning.

“I cannot tell you how many contractors I talk to who are really worried about getting paid,” state Sen. Jessica Ramos said.

Comptroller Brad Lander said the mayor’s contract registration deadlines — which can span up to a year or longer — are “outrageous” and vowed to make shorter deadlines with “consequences” if they’re not met.

Comptroller candidates are jumping on the issue too. Assemblymember Jenifer Rajkumar announced Monday she’d introduce the “Get Nonprofits Paid” Act to require payments within 30 days.

Two weeks before, Council Member Justin Brannan co-authored a City & State op-ed touting a bill that would incentivize the city to make on-time payments.

That same month, Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine raised the issue of late payments to legal services providers in a letter to City Hall, as reported by THE CITY. — Jeff Coltin

MAKING MOVES: Lander’s wife Meg Barnette left her job on Nov. 15 as president and CEO of Nonprofit New York — which co-sponsored Thursday’s mayoral forum.

She joined the advocacy group for the nonprofit sector in 2020, after nine years with Planned Parenthood of Greater New York.

Her role as a registered lobbyist for nonprofits with city business raised ethical concerns, but Lander said he got approval from the Conflicts of Interest Board, noting that Barnette did not lobby for individual clients.

Barnette said she’ll now be supporting Lander’s campaign and will be starting in January as a senior consultant at CFAR Strategies, a management consulting firm.

Jacqueline Ebanks, former executive director of the city’s Commission on Gender Equity, is now serving as Nonprofit New York’s interim president and CEO. — Jeff Coltin

More from the city:

State legislators don’t just run for City Council for a shorter commute — though that’s definitely a factor. (City & State)

Maya Kornberg is challenging far-left City Council Member Shahana Hanif over her strident criticism of Israel. (Jewish Insider)

Loyal Andrew Cuomo aide Melissa DeRosa says the former governor could win the mayoral race if he ran thanks to ranked-choice voting. (New York Post)

 

A message from Uber:

Advertisement Image

 
NEW FROM PLANET ALBANY

Kathy Hochul listens to a press conference.

Gov. Kathy Hochul cited the actuary firm Milliman, whose reports on similar measures are now being called into question by advocates for the bill. | Jacquelyn Martin/AP

FIRST IN PLAYBOOK: Groups pushing Hochul to expand New York’s wrongful death statute are accusing the governor of relying on poor data as she weighs whether or not to veto the measure for the third year in a row.

In 2022 and 2023, both houses of the Legislature sent the Grieving Families Act — a measure that would expand eligibility to sue for damages in the event of a loved one’s wrongful death — to the governor’s desk for her signature.

But Hochul vetoed the legislation each time, often citing the actuary firm Milliman, whose reports on similar measures are now being called into question by advocates for the bill.

In a letter to Attorney General Letitia James, Justice for Grieving Families, a group advocating for the bill, alleges the firm misled lawmakers by saying medical malpractice filings would increase upon the passage of Laverne’s Law — a 2017 law similar to the Grieving Families Act which expanded the ability to sue for medical malpractice upon a missed cancer diagnoses.

In fact, medical malpractice filings have dropped since then, decreasing 12 percent in New York City and 10 percent outside the city. The group also says Milliman predicted insurance premiums would rise by double digits when they’ve actually gone up less than 1 percent annually since 2017.

But Milliman, which declined to speak on the record with Playbook, argued the group’s claims are bogus. The firm said the report cited by the Justice For Grieving Families coalition was based on an earlier version of Laverne’s Law which gave more people the ability to file claims. It also argued a whole host of factors contribute to insurance premiums and filing rates, not just a single law.

“Flawed predictions can mislead legislators and stakeholders, potentially influencing decisions in ways that disadvantage grieving families,” reads the Justice For Grieving Families letter, obtained exclusively by Playbook.

Milliman continues to prepare actuary reports on the Grieving Families Act. Meanwhile, Hochul has until the end of the year to decide if she’ll veto the bill or not.

“We are reviewing the legislation,” her spokesperson Sam Spokony said. — Jason Beeferman

AID IN DYING: A vote in the United Kingdom to advance assisted dying legislation could have reverberations in New York, POLITICO Pro reports.

The House of Commons last month approved a bill that would allow for assisted dying in England and Wales. Under that bill, patients must be diagnosed with having six months or less to live according to two independent doctors. And the decision to die must be free of coercion.

The vote to advance the bill across the Atlantic has generated buzz for the New York proposal, which has stalled for nearly a decade in Albany.

In New York, advocates have pressed for legislation that would allow doctors to prescribe life-ending medication to terminally ill patients.

“The UK Parliament has taken a significant step in addressing critical end-of-life issues that impact everyone,” said Corinne Carey, the campaign director of the advocacy group Compassion & Choices. “We commend their government for engaging in vigorous and thoughtful debate, culminating in this landmark vote.”

Carey added that the advancement of the bill in the House of Commons could spur New York lawmakers to act.

“I know lawmakers are talking about this now and that’s a good thing for our campaign,” she said.

The Democratic-led Legislature is yet to hold a full floor vote on the bill, however. Opponents have contended that allowing patients to end their lives could be abused, especially if a person has a disability.

“Seems like lawmakers know plenty about this issue, and they’ve decided for 10 straight years to reject state-sanctioned suicide and instead focus on suicide prevention, improving mental health supports and other critical issues New Yorkers really want addressed,” said Bob Bellafiore, a spokesperson for the New York State Catholic Conference. — Nick Reisman

BUDGET ASKS: A coalition of more than 250 anti-poverty organizations and left-leaning groups is urging Hochul to expand food assistance benefits when she unveils her budget next month.

The groups — including Feeding New York State and the Labor-Religion Coalition of NYS — in a recent letter to Hochul called for an increase in the monthly allotment to families under the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program.

“With poverty and food insecurity on the rise, our state must step up to ensure all New Yorkers have consistent access to healthy, locally grown, and culturally appropriate foods in their communities,” the groups wrote.

Support from the program increased during the Covid era for qualifying families to about $100 a month. But when emergency allotments ended, the benefit dropped to about $23. — Nick Reisman 

More from Albany:

Hochul is kick-starting negotiations over climate superfund legislation. (POLITICO Pro)

A task force weighing recommendations about mental health and policing will meet next week. (Spectrum News)

New York preschool kids are not receiving special education services. (Times Union)

KEEPING UP WITH THE DELEGATION

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) departs a Senate Democratic Caucus policy luncheon.

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand won an easy reelection. | Francis Chung/POLITICO

WRITE-IN WINNERS: Former U.S. Sen. Al Franken won 257 write-in votes against Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand in New York City — presumably from folks still peeved that she pushed for the Minnesota Democrat’s resignation in 2017 over sexual harassment allegations.

That totals 0.01 percent of the vote, compared to Gillibrand’s 72 percent.

Far more voters chose to protest U.S. policy supporting Israel in its war against Hamas. “Adam Gaza” won the most write-in votes (including slight variations of the name) with 777 and “Hind Rajab” got 441 — totaling 0.05 percent. Both names have been the subject of pro-Palestinian write-in campaigns. Adam Gaza is an invented name, while Hind Rajab was a young girl killed by Israeli forces in Gaza.

Other top write-in votes include former Mayor Michael Bloomberg with 28, Rep. Rashida Tlaib of Michigan with 42 and Rep. Ritchie Torres with 13.

The votes were revealed after the New York City Board of Elections certified its election results Tuesday. The state board plans to certify its results on Monday.

Presidential race rules dictate that write-in votes are only counted for folks who fill out paperwork, so it’s less of a free-for-all than the Senate race. Green Party candidate Jill Stein won there, with 26,443 votes — good for 0.9 percent in the race. — Jeff Coltin

More from Congress:

Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) says Trump’s case in New York was politically motivated. He said Hunter Biden’s case was, too. (The View)

Rep. Marc Molinaro, who lost reelection, discusses his next steps, including a potential bid for Rep. Elise Stefanik’s seat. (WXXI)

Joe Pinion, the former Senate candidate and TV host, joins the pool of special-election contenders seeking Stefanik’s seat. (Daily Gazette)

 

Billions in spending. Critical foreign aid. Immigration reform. The final weeks of 2024 could bring major policy changes. Inside Congress provides daily insights into how Congressional leaders are navigating these high-stakes issues. Subscribe today.

 
 
NEW YORK STATE OF MIND

Corporate security firms could get more business following the murder of the United Healthcare CEO. (Gothamist)

Former Georgia election workers ask yet another judge to hold Rudy Giuliani in contempt. (POLITICO)

The NYPD released new images of the shooter wanted for killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. (Daily News)

 

A message from Uber:

Study Shows Uber Drivers making over $52k while NYC Heroes Get Left Behind

A new study reveals a growing wage divide in New York City: Uber drivers are making an average of $52,900 a year after expenses, while city employees like EMTs and sanitation workers starting salaries are below $44,000. Since 2020, rideshare drivers have received five pay increases through TLC mandates while many frontline city workers face stagnant wages amid rising living costs. This gap underscores an evolving dynamic in NYC’s workforce, where gig workers see consistent earnings growth while essential city roles lag behind. This pay disparity is raising questions about the city’s priorities and the need for equitable wages in public service amidst the affordability crisis.

Read the full story to see how gig work earnings are reshaping NYC’s labor landscape. Learn More.

 
SOCIAL DATA

Edited by Daniel Lippman

MAKING MOVES: Muriel Goode-Trufant confirmed as head of NYC Law Department (NY Daily News)... Yann Hatchuel has joined Fenton as the firm’s vice president of marketing. He was previously Berlin Rosen’s head of marketing.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY: former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo … the Empire Center’s Ken Girardin … BerlinRosen’s Dan LevitanEvelyn FarkasOliver BjornssonJulian Zelizer (55) … Ali Schmidt-FellnerJustin Melvin of the American Bankers Association … Natalie JohnsonBeth ArgamanDana Brisbane (WAS THURSDAY): Matt Gutman ... David M. Schizer ... Pascal Levensohn 

Missed Thursday’s New York Playbook PM? We forgive you. Read it here.

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post