Why Biden shifted on SCOTUS reform

The power players, latest policy developments, and intriguing whispers percolating inside the West Wing.
Jul 29, 2024 View in browser
 
West Wing Playbook

By Eli Stokols, Jonathan Lemire, Lauren Egan and Ben Johansen

Welcome to POLITICO’s West Wing Playbook, your guide to the people and power centers in the Biden administration.

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Eli | Email Lauren

President JOE BIDEN’s push for historic changes to the Supreme Court, when it was drawn up weeks ago, was seen by some aides as an initiative that could shore up support from the Democratic Party base at a precarious political moment — and as a genuine and important evolution in Biden’s position over just the past several months.

Biden’s speech at the LBJ Library in Austin was initially scheduled for the first night of the Republican convention, but it was pulled down after former President DONALD TRUMP was shot just days before. Aides rescheduled it for last week, but that was delayed, too, after the president’s decision to end his reelection bid.

When he finally outlined his proposal on Monday afternoon, Biden was no longer his party’s presidential candidate or its main character. And the proposal is now being viewed largely through the lens of how it may affect Vice President KAMALA HARRIS’ campaign and, to a lesser extent, his own legacy.

Biden opposed structural changes to the Court in 2022 following the Dobbs decision that ended 50 years of federal abortion protections. But he changed his mind once news broke of justices’ ethical lapses and the Court’s ruling just weeks ago giving presidents immunity for crimes they may commit while in office, according to four officials who were granted anonymity to talk about private conversations.

“We’ve seen some real red flags [in recent months],” said STEVE BENJAMIN, the director of the White House Office of Public Engagement, explaining the president’s evolution on the matter to reporters aboard Air Force One on Monday en route to Texas.

Since taking office, Biden had grown increasingly frustrated with the rightward lean of the high court, finding many of its decisions — on voting rights, student loans and abortion — out of step with the majority of Americans, the officials said. But he was reluctant to propose major changes to the court; early in his term, a study of the court that could have led to some reforms was largely swept aside.

But over the last year, he grew more open to considering reforms. He raised the subject at a gathering of historians and legal scholars at the White House earlier this year, according to one of the officials and one other person familiar with the meeting. And when the Supreme Court issued its ruling earlier this month granting presidents broad immunity for actions while in office, Biden was incensed and deemed the decision “a dangerous precedent” that “undermines the rule of law.”

That decision accelerated the work that was already underway. And it came just days after Biden’s disastrous debate performance and his team’s frantic efforts to rebuild support. Ideas to reform the court had long been championed by Democrats and its popularity convinced the Biden team to push forward. The president himself first hinted at the plan during a July 13 Zoom call with the Congressional Progressive Caucus while he was still running for reelection, according to a recording first obtained by The Washington Post.

He pointed to all of it in an op-ed published by The Washington Post on Monday that laid out his plan: 18-year term limits and a binding ethical code for the court, along with an end to blanket criminal immunity for presidents.

“What is happening now is not normal, and it undermines the public’s confidence in the court’s decisions,” Biden wrote.

As a committed institutionalist who’s overseen Supreme Court nominations as the former chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee and now appointed a justice to the court himself, Biden noted he does not take this position lightly, nor did he come to it quickly. The bigger question is how seriously people take his effort now that the president is no longer a candidate and that Congress isn’t likely to act on any of this any time soon.

"I have great respect for our institutions, for the separation of powers laid out in our constitution," Biden said in his remarks from the LBJ Library. "But what's happening now is not consistent with that doctrine of separation of powers."

Railing against the Supreme Court's immunity ruling, which he said was a decision granted to serve Trump's interests alone, Biden continued: "We're a nation of laws, not kings and dictators."

While Biden has abandoned his own reelection bid, his aides believe the proposal — even if it’s all but certain to go down to defeat — could become part of his legacy and lay a framework for future reform, the officials said.

In the short term, the new push offers an early look at how Biden and Harris will work in tandem now that she, not he, has become the party’s standard bearer. How much the White House and Harris campaign make these proposals a central focus remains to be seen, but there is no daylight between them on the substance.

Before she’d replaced Biden atop the ticket, Harris was consulted about the president’s plan to call for reforms with the president and his aides citing her work on the Senate Judiciary Committee and her experience as California state Attorney General, according to one of the officials.

On Monday, Harris’ campaign quickly put out a statement endorsing the plan, describing it as a joint effort.

“President Biden and I strongly believe that the American people must have confidence in the Supreme Court. Yet today, there is a clear crisis of confidence facing the Supreme Court as its fairness has been called into question after numerous ethics scandals and decision after decision overturning long-standing precedent,” she said. “That is why President Biden and I are calling on Congress to pass important reforms.”

MESSAGE US — Are you Chief Justice JOHN ROBERTS? We want to hear from you. And we’ll keep you anonymous! Email us at westwingtips@politico.com.

Did someone forward this email to you? Subscribe here

 

Pro Briefing: Kamala Harris and the World. What we expect on foreign policy and trade. Join POLITICO Pro for a deep-dive conversation with our specialist reporters about the vice president’s approach to foreign policy. Register Now.

 
 
POTUS PUZZLER

Which U.S. Olympic gold medalist performed for guests at a White House Christmas reception in 1980?

(Answer at bottom.)

The Oval

PAYING RESPECTS: After the event at the LBJ Library, President Biden is expected to travel to Houston to pay respects to Rep. SHEILA JACKSON LEE, who died on July 19 after being treated for pancreatic cancer.

BRAINSTORM SESH: During his gaggle with reporters aboard Air Force One, Steve Benjamin also said that the president and top aides were discussing how to maximize his final six months in office. “It's happening as recently as on this plane,” he said. There were a whole bunch of lawmakers (and close Biden allies) on the flight manifest: Sen. CHRIS COONS (D-Del.), Sen. RAPHAEL WARNOCK (D-Ga.), Sen. ALEX PADILLA (D-Calif.), Rep. JIM CLYBURN (D-S.C.) and Rep. STEVEN HORSFORD (D-Nev.).

Rev. Al Sharpton post on X 7/29

EVERYONE CAN BE A LITTLE GRUMPY AFTER A LONG FLIGHT: A reporter on the tarmac in Austin asked the president to respond to House Speaker MIKE JOHNSON’s comments that the Supreme Court reform package is “dead on arrival” and would not be considered in the House.

“I think that's what he is,” Biden shot back. “He is — dead on arrival.”

WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE WANTS YOU TO READ: The Biden administration announced Monday morning that it’s protecting over 600,000 Teamsters workers and retirees from seeing “devastating cuts” to their pension funds. The action will protect pensions for 70,000 workers and retirees in New England, per a statement from President Biden. To date, Biden said his administration has protected more than 40,000 Teamsters in Ohio and Michigan, more than 30,000 in Illinois and Missouri, and more than 20,000 in Wisconsin, Minnesota and Pennsylvania.

Senior adviser to the chief of staff SALONI SHARMA shared the statement on X, writing: “President Biden and Congressional Democrats — without a single vote of support from Congressional Republicans — worked to protect the pensions of over 1 million union workers.”

White House political director EMMY RUIZ, deputy press secretary ANDREW BATES and communications director BEN LaBOLT also posted the news.

WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE DOESN’T WANT YOU TO READ: This piece by WSJ’s AARON ZITNER and ANDREW RESTUCCIA about the growing political divide between young men and women that is cutting into the Democratic Party’s base.

“Voters under 30 have been a pillar of the Democratic coalition since Ronald Reagan left office in 1989. That pillar is showing cracks, with young men defecting from the party,” they write. “Young men now favor Republican control of Congress and Trump for president after backing President Biden and Democratic lawmakers in 2020.”

“The question now is whether Harris, the expected Democratic nominee, will recapture the support of young men or push more of them away,” they continue.

JILL IN PARIS: President Biden might be stuck at home but the first lady was living her best life at the Paris Olympics. NYT’s ALYSON KRUEGER spotted JILL BIDEN and granddaughter NAOMI BIDEN at Ralph’s Restaurant Paris on the first weekend of the games, mingling with nearly 200 other attendees at an event hosted by fashion brand Ralph Lauren. Krueger writes that the bash “felt a little like an unofficial embassy for the high-profile Americans in Paris,” with notable names like actress JESSICA CHASTAIN, boy-band icon NICK JONAS, influencer EMMA CHAMBERLAIN and snowboarder SHAUN WHITE drinking martinis and snacking on a raw bar.

The first lady and her grandchildren lingered into the later hours of the night, even as the crowd dispersed. One guest even commented: “I can’t believe I am leaving a party before Jill Biden.”

CAMPAIGN HQ

WHAT SHE SAID VS. WHAT SHE MEANT: The Harris campaign on Monday clarified that the vice president’s broad pledge to “restore reproductive freedom” actually just means she’s calling to restore Roe v. Wade. As our MEGAN MESSERLY and ALICE MIRANDA OLLSTEIN report, that doesn’t go as far as some abortion-rights activists were hoping— though they’re not all that surprised and are largely backing Harris.

“The details come as Harris finds her footing as a presidential candidate separate from Biden,” Messerly and Ollstein write, and “the promise to restore Roe is the latest example of the more moderate path she is taking as likely presidential nominee compared with her platform when she first ran for the office in 2019.”

THE VOLATILE ISRAEL TEST: Over the last week, Vice President Harris has found herself caught in an intractable issue — Israel and its war in Gaza — our BLAKE JONES, SALLY GOLDENBERG, EUGENE DANIELS and SHIA KAPOS report. A person of color who’s voiced measured support for pro-Palestinian protesters and in turn, has been vulnerable to GOP attacks, Harris is taking a gamble and trying to occupy the middle ground.

JD, SHE’S COMING FOR YOU: Kamala Harris was planning to brush past Ohio Sen. JD VANCE when they were competing Veep to aspiring Veep. Now that she’s the nominee, she’s recasting the Republican as a major liability and knocking Donald Trump’s decision to anoint him as his running mate, CNN’s EDWARD-ISAAC DOVERE reports. The campaign is poking holes in Vance’s resume (arguing his qualifications don’t go beyond the constitutional minimum of being a naturally born citizen above the age of 35) and putting Trump’s age in focus (pointing out how easily Vance could become president if something happens to the 78-year-old).

“I’ve done a lot of hiring in my life — in business and nonprofits, in government — and it’s pretty obvious when someone’s resume shows that they can’t hold down a job or haven’t held down a job for more than a year or two at a time, that there’s something wrong with them,” Illinois Gov. JB PRITZKER, who’s being vetted for the Harris veepstakes, said in reference to Vance’s work history before he ran for Senate in 2022.

SPEAKING OF VEEPSTAKES, EVERYONE’S GOT AN OPINION: At least, several liberal columnists do. And in a truncated vetting and selection process, every public appearance, social media post and supportive op-ed — to the extent those things reflect real enthusiasm — may matter slightly more to those helping Harris decide.

Sen. MARK KELLY (D-Ariz.) has fans in WaPo’s KAREN TUMULTY and ERIKA D. SMITH of Bloomberg. A gun owner, retired Navy pilot and astronaut, Kelly offers a “dazzling” biography and would “help inoculate” Harris where she’s vulnerable, Tumulty writes.

JONATHAN ALTER (and much of liberal Twitter) is all in for Minnesota Gov. TIM WALZ, who’s got, Alter writes in the NYT, “Midwestern charm” and a “resume that looks as if it was designed in a lab.” Bloomberg’s PATRICIA LOPEZ is also arguing for Walz, whose small town roots and background as a teacher and military veteran “could help balance a ticket with Harris.”

MATT YGLESIAS wants Secretary/Mayor PETE BUTTIGIEG. Because of course he does. “My rationale is simple: Buttigieg is very good on TV, and that is a large part of the job description for a vice presidential candidate,” Yglesias writes for Bloomberg Opinion.

And DAVID FARIS chimes in with a vote for Michigan Gov. GRETCHEN WHITMER in Slate. Two women on the ticket, he argues, is not a problem, while asserting that “Big Gretch,” who has said she’s not interested in the job, “is the only rumored vice presidential candidate without any meaningful downside.”

THE BUREAUCRATS

BUSY BEE BUTTIGIEG: The Transportation Secretary is appearing on The Daily Show tonight, where he’s sure to cement himself as the thirstiest (or perhaps the most in demand?) veep contender.

Agenda Setting

SOME SHAMELESS SELF-PROMO: We’re three weeks out from the Democratic National Convention, but the Chicago Sun-Times has already identified the hottest place you’ll want to “see and be seen”: The CNN-POLITICO Grill, a pop-up Chicago food and beverage-themed restaurant. We’re biased, but can confirm. For proof: The version of the Grill at the Republican National Convention pulled a range of high-profile speakers, from House Speaker Mike Johnson to Arkansas Gov. SARAH HUCKABEE SANDERS.

What We're Reading

Trump vs. Biden’s historic climate agenda (POLITICO’s Kelsey Tamborrino, Timothy Cama and Jessie Blaeser)

Opinion: Kamala Harris’ often-mocked speaking style is the strongest tool in her arsenal (LAT’s Cydney Hurston Dupree)

Harris Camp Warns Supporters: Don’t Get Duped by ‘Scam PACs’ (The Bulwark’s Sam Stein)

POTUS PUZZLER ANSWER

Figure skater PEGGY FLEMING performed on an ice stage set up on the South Lawn of the White House for President JIMMY CARTER and his guests at a holiday party on December 22, 1980.

According to the White House Historical Association, the “elaborate event featured artificial snow, eggnog, hot cocoa, and sleigh rides” and “Fleming skated three times for the audience throughout the afternoon.”

A CALL OUT! Do you think you have a harder trivia question? Send us your best one about the presidents, with a citation or sourcing, and we may feature it!

Edited by Steve Shepard and Rishika Dugyala

 

SUBSCRIBE TO GLOBAL PLAYBOOK: Don’t miss out on POLITICO’s Global Playbook, our newsletter taking you inside pivotal discussions at the most influential gatherings in the world. Suzanne Lynch delivers the world's elite and influential moments directly to you. Stay in the global loop. SUBSCRIBE NOW.

 
 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Eli Stokols @EliStokols

Lauren Egan @Lauren_V_Egan

Ben Johansen @BenJohansen3

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to salenamartine360.news1@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post