J.D. Vance wasn't always like this.
He grew up poor in Middletown, Ohio — escaping a difficult childhood to make it to Yale Law and, subsequently, to the lucrative world of venture capital. This narrative served as the backbone of his 2016 book, Hillbilly Elegy, that turned into a mega-bestseller: a book that seemed to explain Trump's appeal to America's downtrodden. It put Vance on the national map.
The Vance of Hillbilly Elegy was very different politically. Back then, he took a conventional conservative line on poverty, describing the working class as beset by a cultural pathology encouraged by federal handouts and the welfare state.
2016 Vance was also an ardent Trump foe. He wrote a New York Times op-ed titled "Mr. Trump Is Unfit For Our Nation's Highest Office," and wrote a text to his law school roommate warning that Trump might be "America's Hitler."
Eight years later, Vance has metamorphosed into something else entirely. Today, he pitches himself as an economic populist and cosponsors legislation with Sen. Elizabeth Warren curtailing pay for failed bankers. In an even more extreme shift, he has morphed into one of Trump's leading champions in the Senate — backing the former president to the hilt and even, at times, outpacing him in anti-democratic fervor.
When I spoke to Georgia state Sen. Josh McLaurin (D) — the former law school roommate who had received Vance's "America's Hitler" text — I asked him how the Vance he knew evolved into the Vance we see today.
"The through line between former J.D. and current J.D. is anger," McLaurin told me. "The Trump turn can be understood as a lock-in on contempt as the answer to anger" — specifically, contempt directed at Vance's political enemies.
McLaurin's comments suggest that Vance's conversion to Trumpism is genuine. I'm inclined to agree, though the timing of his MAGA conversion surely is convenient: He converted to right-wing populism just in time to run for a vacant seat in Trumpy Ohio.
Ultimately, whether Vance truly believes what he's saying is secondary to the public persona he's chosen to adopt. Politicians are not defined by their inner lives, but the decisions that they make in public — the ones that actually affect law and policy. Those choices are deeply shaped by the constituencies they depend on and the allies they court.
And it is clear that Vance is deeply ensconced in the GOP's growing "national conservative" faction, which pairs an inconsistent economic populism with an authoritarian commitment to crushing liberals in the culture war.
Vance has cited Curtis Yarvin, a Silicon Valley monarchist blogger, as the source of his ideas about firing bureaucrats and defying the Supreme Court. His Senate campaign was funded by Vance's former employer, Peter Thiel, a billionaire who once wrote that "I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible."
He's a big fan of Patrick Deneen, a Notre Dame professor who recently wrote a book calling for "regime change" in America. Vance spoke at an event for Deneen's book in Washington, describing himself as a member of the "postliberal right" who sees his job in Congress as taking an "explicitly anti-regime" stance.
Vance is also an open admirer of Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, a right-wing politician who has systematically torn his country's democracy apart. Vance praised Orbán's approach to higher education in particular, saying he "made some smart decisions there that we could learn from in the United States." The policies in question involve using national dollars to impose state controls over universities, turning them into vehicles for disseminating the government line.
In a profile of Vance, Politico reporter Ian Ward quotes multiple leading Republican figures — specifically, the leaders of the faction trying to turn these postliberal ideas into practice — saying that they see Vance as a leading advocate for their cause.
Top Trump advisor (and current federal inmate) Steve Bannon told Wardthat Vance is "at the nerve center of this movement." Kevin Roberts, the president of the right-wing Heritage Foundation and the driving force behind Project 2025, told Ward that "he is absolutely going to be one of the leaders — if not the leader — of our movement."
